The Cost of Ambition in The Making of Mr. Lincoln Production
The Oberlin Musical Theater Association’s recent production of The Making of Mr. Lincoln examines the heavy toll of creative ambition, tracking how inventors traded personal fulfillment for a lasting, yet ultimately hollow, legacy.
Written and directed by Wesley Brubaker, the play premiered following 18 months of intensive writing and years of research.
Five inventors seek a future
The play’s first act focuses on five Disney inventors: Marc Davis, Roger Broggie, James Algar, Bob Gurr, and Jack Gladish. These figures dedicated their careers to the development of an animatronic Abraham Lincoln, The Oberlin Review reported. During this period, they were among the company’s most vital creative forces.
Walt Disney and his board promised the team a bright, innovative vision of the future. This prospect kept the inventors focused through years of mechanical testing and long nights. Eventually, however, the pressure of high expectations caused the initial excitement to wane. The inventors began leaving the project, seeking to reclaim the passion they felt before the mechanical work consumed their lives.
The cost of artistic perfection
The production highlights the tension between the desire for technical perfection and the reality of human experience. Eleanor Albers, the play’s assistant director, noted the complexity of this conflict. “I think that this play really explores the tension between desiring perfection out of art, and what art is really ultimately meant to be, which is a flawed but authentic representation of a human experience,” Albers told The Oberlin Review.
By the second act, Marc Davis remains the sole inventor working directly under Walt Disney. He continues to toil on the Lincoln project, setting aside his own creative interests. It is not until Disney is hospitalized that the original five inventors reunite. During this meeting, Broggie encourages Davis to recognize that his ongoing work may no longer justify the personal cost.
Legacy versus individual fulfillment
Davis reveals a desire to be remembered, hoping to produce something that will be recognized 10, 20, or even 30 years in the future. The play challenges this ambition, suggesting that the world inevitably shifts its attention to the next innovation. “You can put all of this effort into this innovation, into this perfect model, perfect product, but people are just gonna want to go to the next thing,” Albers said.
This struggle often mirrors the challenges faced by modern creative professionals and entrepreneurs who find their personal goals sidelined by the demands of institutional legacy.
A cruel fate for an industrialist
The production concludes with a striking parallel between the Lincoln animatronic and Walt Disney himself. While Davis eventually acknowledges the need to stop following external expectations, Disney remains committed to his vision until the end. The final scenes depict Disney being reduced to the very thing he helped create, a fate that contradicts his original goals.
“The somewhat cruel fate that Walt Disney receives [is] being remembered in this way,” Brubaker told The Oberlin Review. “He wanted the complete opposite thing: To be remembered for this incredible city and this American industrialist legacy. That has been his driving motivation for the whole story. To be relegated to this animatronic as, as he did to Lincoln, is a cruel fate for him.”
Beyond his work as a playwright, Wesley Brubaker is a student actor who has performed in other campus theater productions. In these roles, he has explored complex characters navigating internal struggles, demonstrating a range that informs his approach to writing and directing character-driven narratives.
The play serves as a meditation on the trade-offs inherent in long-term projects. It questions whether the pursuit of a lasting legacy is worth the loss of the creative joy that initially motivated the work.
For those balancing personal creative goals against the demands of large-scale, long-term development, the production emphasizes that the world moves on regardless of the effort invested. When the focus shifts entirely to the output rather than the creator, the result may be a product that survives, but a person who is left behind.