Indonesia‘s Football challenges: A Realistic Assessment
The current expectations surrounding the Indonesian national football team are unrealistic,particularly given the recent influx of naturalized players and the state of domestic football. Qualifying for a World Cup instantly isn’t feasible, and coach Shin Tae-yong deserves time – at least until the 2027 Asian Cup – to build a cohesive team.
A significant issue is the lack of nuanced football understanding amongst many Indonesian fans and, crucially, the media. Unrealistic benchmarks, like comparing Indonesia to clubs like PSG or Manchester City, fuel a harsh and unreflective criticism that hinders progress. Integrating naturalized players is inherently challenging, and the relatively low physical level of the domestic league further complicates matters. World Cup qualification should be viewed as a potential long-term sensation, not a short-term expectation.
Indonesia faces a deeper cultural problem: a profound impatience. Planning horizons are short-term, and there’s a desire for instant results. This impatience extends beyond football, contributing to economic stagnation and social issues.While the enthusiasm for football is undeniable – vividly demonstrated by the nationwide celebrations following goals – this emotionality often translates into unrealistic demands.
This impatience is linked to broader societal challenges. The country struggles with economic hardship, evidenced by a significant decline in the middle class.Political and social issues, like the stance on Israel, are often driven by emotion rather than understanding.
Indonesia could benefit from adopting a more long-term,strategic approach,mirroring the success seen in badminton,which was fueled by private investment and structured training. However, progress is hampered by underlying racism and a growing sense of disillusionment amongst the youth, leading to a ”go away first” mentality.
While there’s a strong base of sports enthusiasts and promising grassroots participation, a lack of professional structures and, crucially, patience prevents this potential from being realized. Even the team’s most prominent local player couldn’t secure a position in Poland’s second division, highlighting the gap in talent.
Ultimately, Indonesia is a country with immense potential and passionate fans, but overcoming these deeply ingrained cultural and structural challenges will be crucial for long-term footballing success.