‘Superman‘ Flies to HBO Max this Week – But Is a Rewatch Worth It?
September 16, 2025 – james Gunn‘s reimagining of Superman has sparked considerable debate since its release, concurrently generating excitement for a revitalized DC Universe and drawing fire from fans nostalgic for Henry Cavill‘s portrayal and Zack Snyder’s vision. It’s also faced criticism from viewers simply underwhelmed by the final product.
And, as Forbes contributor Erik Kain notes, he falls squarely into that latter camp. While praising David Corenswet’s performance as the Man of Steel – stating he’s “a great choice and did a terrific job” – Kain’s core issue lies with the film’s writing and direction.
“Like Snyder, Gunn has a very distinct style,” Kain explains. “Neither director was the right choice for Superman.” (You can read his detailed review here.)
Kain’s personal barometer for a truly great film is simple: immediate rewatchability.While some movies compel a return to the theater within days – like this year’s critically acclaimed Weapons - others linger in the realm of