Eli Apple: A Career of Potential and unfulfilled promise

Eli Apple, a former first-round NFL draft pick, recently found himself released by the San Francisco 49ers, leaving his future in the league uncertain. His career has been a narrative of tantalizing athleticism and high expectations often overshadowed by inconsistency and struggles to fully realize his potential.

Early Struggles and Lessons Learned in New York

Drafted 10th overall by the New York Giants in 2016, Apple entered the NFL with critically important hype. However, his initial years were marked by growing pains. He openly admitted to trying to do too much, too soon. In a Q&A with ReadWrite’s Kyle Odegard, Apple reflected on his early struggles, stating, “Being a young guy coming in, you try to balance everything, and you try to play Superman…Sometimes its tough…That was my mistake, trying to do too much.” This self-awareness highlighted a willingness to learn, but translating that into on-field performance proved challenging.

Searching for a Consistent Role

A trade sent Apple to the New Orleans Saints in 2018, offering a fresh start. He showed glimpses of promise in the Big Easy, recording two interceptions and 14 passes defended. However, 2019 brought a setback, as he failed to secure an interception, signaling a stall in his progress.

A Career Peak in Cincinnati

Apple’s most impactful season arrived in 2021 with the Cincinnati Bengals. He became a key contributor at cornerback, registering two interceptions during the regular season and playing a vital role in the Bengals’ unexpected Super Bowl run. While Cincinnati ultimately fell short of the championship, Apple’s performance that year stands as a clear high point in his professional career.

NFL Statistics: A Mixed Bag

Over nine seasons, Apple has suited up for the Giants, Saints, Carolina Panthers, bengals, and a brief stint with the 49ers. He’s appeared in 88 games (73 starts), accumulating five interceptions, 53 passes defended, and 317 total tackles. His 2021 campaign with the Bengals, where he started 15 games and recorded two interceptions alongside 10 passes defended, represents his most statistically productive year. Despite his undeniable athleticism and initial draft position, Apple has consistently battled with coverage consistency and a tendency towards penalties.

Foundation Built at Ohio State

Before entering the NFL,Apple established himself as a standout player at Ohio State University from 2013 to 2015. He immediately contributed as a true freshman, appearing in all 14 games and earning a single start. His sophomore year saw him become a full-time starter during the Buckeyes’ 2014 national Championship-winning season.

He recorded 33 tackles, one interception, and seven passes defended that year, demonstrating his ability to compete against elite college competition. His junior year continued this trajectory, with 33 tackles, one interception, and eight passes defended, culminating in First-Team All-Big Ten honors. His time in Columbus showcased his speed, athleticism, and potential as a shutdown corner, fueling his high draft stock.

Apple’s experience within Ohio State’s demanding program and crucial playoff moments undoubtedly prepared him for the pressures of the NFL,though replicating that success at the professional level has proven elusive.

Looking Ahead

Now a 30-year-old veteran, Apple faces an uncertain future. While he still possesses the physical attributes to compete, he needs a team willing to believe in his potential and provide an opportunity. His experience and resilience could still carve out a role for him in the league, but he’ll need to demonstrate a level of consistency that has often been missing throughout his career.

This story is based on reporting originally published by