“`html
Manchester United Crumbles in Derby: City Dominates 3-0
Table of Contents
Analysis of a disappointing performance for the Red Devils, raising questions about the future under Ruben Amorim.
Manchester United suffered a comprehensive 3-0 defeat to Manchester City at the Etihad Stadium on Sunday, September 14th, continuing a troubling start to the 2025/26 Premier League season.The result leaves Ruben Amorim’s side with just four points from their opening four matches, and a challenging fixture list looms, including an upcoming clash with Chelsea.
match Summary: City’s clinical Display
Manchester City controlled the game from start to finish. Phil Foden opened the scoring, with Erling Haaland adding two second-half goals to seal the victory. Jeremy Doku’s electrifying performance on the wing caused constant problems for the United defense.
Player Ratings: A Dismal Showing for the Red devils
GOAL provided a scathing assessment of the Manchester United players, and the following reflects a summary of their key observations:
| Player | Rating (Out of 10) | key Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Luke Shaw | 3/10 | Largely responsible for all three city goals, unable to contain Foden and consistently beaten. |
| Benjamin Sesko | 4/10 | A disappointing full debut, failing to make an impact on the attack and highlighting United’s offensive struggles. |
| Altay Bayindir | 6/10 | Avoided any major errors, but lacked the confidence to inspire the team. |
| Gianluigi Donnarumma (Man City) | 8/10 | Made a crucial save from Bryan Mbeumo,demonstrating his quality. |
Luke Shaw: A Performance to Forget
The performance of Luke Shaw was notably concerning. He was directly at fault for the opening goal and struggled throughout the match to cope with the pace and skill of the City attackers.His form represents a important weakness in an already fragile United backline.
Sesko’s Disappointing Debut
Much was expected of Benjamin Sesko on his first start for Manchester United, but he failed to deliver. His lack of involvement in the attacking play underscored the team’s broader issues in front of goal.
Goalkeeping Contrast: Bayindir vs. Donnarumma
While Altay Bayindir didn’t commit any glaring errors, his performance lacked the assurance displayed by Manchester City’s new goalkeeper, Gianluigi Donnarumma, who made a vital save to maintain City’s advantage.
Looking ahead: pressure Mounts on Amorim
This defeat intensifies the pressure on manager Ruben Amorim. With a tough run of fixtures ahead, including a match against Chelsea, United urgently need to address their defensive vulnerabilities and find a way to unlock their attacking potential. The question remains: can Amorim turn things around?