Bontempelli’s Future Questioned Amidst Allen’s Injury Concerns

Pies’ Pursuit of Bontempelli Stalled, Allen Faces Contract Hurdles

As the AFL season unfolds, the Collingwood Magpies’ interest in securing star midfielder Marcus Bontempelli has been rebuffed. Meanwhile, West Coast Eagles co-captain Oscar Allen confronts uncertainty due to injury and contract negotiations, adding complexity to the trade landscape.

Collingwood’s Unsuccessful Overtures

Reports indicate the Collingwood Football Club tested the waters with Marcus Bontempelli, making contact to gauge his interest in a move. However, the Western Bulldogs’ response was clear: “don’t waste your time.”

Inside the Pies’ sneaky play for Marcus Bontempelli and the “series of overtures” that were repeatedly turned back. Plus, why a great believes lucrative contract offers made to West Coast’s oft-injured co-captain are “irresponsible”. Stay up to date with the latest player movement developments with AFL Trade Whispers! pic.twitter.com/wL1j90F4wY

— Fox Footy (@FOXFOOTY) June 16, 2025

Jon Ralph from the Herald Sun shared insights on the matter, noting the Magpies’ persistent but unsuccessful attempts to lure Bontempelli. The Dogs’ skipper is yet to agree to a contract past 2025, leaving some fans restless.

Allen’s Contract and Injury Dilemma

Former Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley weighed in on the situation of Oscar Allen, suggesting caution regarding a long-term, high-value contract for the injured player. Allen has battled injuries and is considered a key figure.

“Oscar Allen’s contract scenario is almost as saddest story in football. He’s desperate to play for the club that he’s a co-captain of.”

—Jon Ralph

Buckley also mentioned it would be “irresponsible” to offer Allen an extended contract given his injury history. Player injuries can have a significant impact, with a recent study showing a 15% decrease in team performance when key players are sidelined (AFL Research, 2025).

Strategic Considerations

Allen played only eleven games last season. Buckley suggested if such a deal were to be offered, it would need to include clauses protecting the club should the player be unavailable. The conversation suggests that both clubs and players must carefully consider the risk.