Former State trooper Faces Scrutiny as Evidence Dispute Mirrors Past Accusations
Norfolk, MA – August 6, 2025 – A former Massachusetts State Trooper, identified as “Porky Proctor” in online commentary, is alleging delays in the release of evidence related to his current legal issues, a situation critics point out echoes past accusations leveled against him regarding evidence handling in a separate murder case. The dispute has reignited debate surrounding transparency and accountability within the Massachusetts state Police.
The current situation involves Proctor’s own legal defense, where he claims the State Police are not providing requested evidence in a timely manner. This has drawn sharp criticism from observers who recall the case of a man held for over three years while awaiting evidence in a murder inquiry – a case where Proctor was accused of withholding evidence.
The irony of Proctor now complaining about evidence delays has not been lost on those following the case. Commentators have highlighted a pattern of alleged misconduct within the Massachusetts State Police, citing instances of troopers facing accusations of soliciting gifts, framing innocent individuals, and exhibiting disturbing behavior towards victims.
this latest development occurs alongside ongoing legal battles stemming from the controversial Karen Read case. A hearing is scheduled for next week to possibly unseal text messages from Norfolk Police Officer Michael morrissey, which are expected to shed further light on the investigation. The blog Turtleboy, a prominent voice covering the case, claims to already possess these texts and anticipates their release will reveal further issues with the conduct of law enforcement in Norfolk County.
simultaneously occurring, legal counsel for Karen Read are finalizing a civil rights lawsuit under Section 1983, to be filed in federal court. This move is intended to bypass Judge Beverly Cannone, who presided over Read’s two criminal trials, both of which ended in acquittals. Read’s legal team has been critical of cannone’s rulings, alleging bias and the exclusion of exculpatory evidence. Cannone has as been transferred to Plymouth County, prompting speculation about potential involvement in the upcoming civil lawsuit.
Background: The Karen Read Case and Ongoing Concerns
The Karen Read case centers around the death of Joseph Kennedy III in Canton, Massachusetts, in January 2022. Read was initially charged with his murder but was acquitted in two separate trials. The case gained meaningful public attention due to questions surrounding the investigation, the handling of evidence, and the conduct of law enforcement officials.
The controversy has fueled broader concerns about potential misconduct within the Massachusetts State Police and Norfolk County law enforcement. Allegations have included improper evidence handling, biased investigations, and a lack of transparency.The upcoming release of Morrissey’s texts and the filing of Read’s civil rights lawsuit are expected to further scrutinize these issues.
The case highlights the importance of independent oversight and accountability within law enforcement agencies,and the potential consequences when those principles are compromised. The legal battles surrounding the Karen Read case and the scrutiny of figures like proctor are likely to continue shaping the conversation around police conduct and justice in Massachusetts for the foreseeable future.