Carragher Questions Luis Díaz’s Impact at Liverpool, Calls Sale “Good Deal”
MUNICH, GERMANY – December 2, 2025 – Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher delivered a pointed assessment of Luis Díaz’s time at Anfield, asserting the Colombian international was a “good player” but lacked the elite quality of former teammates Mohamed Salah, Sadio Mané, and Roberto Firmino. Carragher’s comments, surfacing amidst Díaz’s current stint with Bayern Munich, have ignited debate about the winger’s overall contribution to Liverpool and the club’s decision to sell him.
The remarks come as Díaz prepares for Bayern Munich’s German Cup round of 16 clash against Union berlin on Wednesday, December 3rd. While the Colombian continues to strive for success in Germany, Carragher’s evaluation underscores a broader discussion about player valuation and the strategic decisions made by top-tier football clubs. The criticism raises questions about how Díaz is perceived within the landscape of Premier League stars and the financial considerations that drove his transfer.
Carragher stated unequivocally, “Díaz was a good player for Liverpool, but he was not excellent: he was not Firmino, he was not Mané, he was not Salah.” He further suggested Liverpool maximized their return on investment, adding, “Liverpool took advantage of him for a few years and got a good asking price; it was a good deal for Liverpool.”
The comments have prompted reactions from fans and pundits alike, with some defending Díaz’s contributions to Liverpool’s attack and others acknowledging Carragher’s point about the presence of established superstars during his time at the club. Díaz joined Bayern Munich seeking a fresh start and increased playing time, and will aim to silence critics with continued strong performances for the Bundesliga giants.
Alexandra BEIER / AFP photo credit.