Brandon Routh

James Gunn’s Superman, starring David Corenswet in the title role, is new in theaters this week, and soon fans will find out how the writer-director’s version rates against the Superman movies that came before it.

Superman, which is written and directed by Gunn, plays in Thursday previews before opening Friday in theaters nationwide. The official summary for Superman partially reads, “When Superman (Corenswet) is drawn into conflicts both abroad and at home, his actions to protect humankind are questioned, and his vulnerability allows tech billionaire and master deceiver Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult) to leverage the opportunity to get Superman out of the way for good.

“Will the Daily Planet’s intrepid reporter Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan) together with the aid of Metropolis’s other metahumans and Superman’s own four-legged companion, Krypto, be able to help Superman before Luthor can completely destroy him?”

Superman marks the seventh solo movie about DC Comics’ Man of Steel from Warner Bros., which began in 1978 with the release of Superman: The Movie, starring the late Christopher Reeve as Clark Kent/Superman.

ForbesWimbledon 2025: See Photos Of Biggest Celebrities Attending MatchesBy Tim Lammers

Listed below are Rotten Tomatoes critics’ ratings for the first six Superman films, from worst to best.

Since this is a list of Superman’s solo films, the list does not include 2016’s Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice, which featured the DC superhero trio of Superman (Henry Cavill), Batman (Ben Affleck) and Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot), or either cut of Justice League.

‘Superman IV: The Quest For Peace’ (1987)

The fourth and final film starring Christopher Reeve as Superman/Clark Kent was blasted by Rotten Tomatoes critics, who collectively gave the film a 14% “rotten” rating based on 114 viewers. Audiences, meanwhile, gave the film a 16% “rotten” score on RT’s Popcornmeter based on 50,000-plus verified user ratings.

The RT Consensus for Superman IV: Quest for Peace reads, “The Superman series bottoms with The Quest for Peace — the action is boring, the special effects look cheaper, and none of the actors appear interested in where the plot’s going.”

‘Superman III’ (1983)

Neither comedy legend Richard Pryor nor The Man From U.N.C.L.E. star Robert Vaughn could help Christopher Reeve give lift to the third Superhero chapter, which Rotten Tomatoes critics gave a 29% “rotten” rating based on 79 reviews.

Audiences found even less to be enthused about with Superman III, as the movie earned a 23% “rotten” Popcornmeter score based on 100,000-plus user ratings.

The RT Critics Consensus for the film reads, When not overusing sight gags, slapstick, and Richard Pryor, Superman III resorts to plot points rehashed from the previous Superman flicks.”

‘Man Of Steel’ (2013)

Starring Henry Cavill as Superman/Clark Kent and Amy Adams as Lois Lane, Man of Steel marked the second reboot attempt of the Superman franchise by Warner Bros.

Grounded in real-world sensibilities like Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight movies, Nolan and David S. Goyer wrote the screen story while Goyer wrote the screenplay for Man of Steel with Zack Snyder in the director’s chair.

ForbesTim Burton Says He’s Working On A New Animated ProjectBy Tim Lammers

While Rotten Tomatoes critics gave Man of Steel a 57% “rotten” rating based on 327 reviews, audiences embraced the film with a 75% “fresh” rating on RT’s Popcornmeter based on 250,000 user ratings.

The RT Critics Consensus for Man of Steel reads, “Man of Steel‘s exhilarating action and spectacle can’t fully overcome its detours into generic blockbuster territory.”

‘Superman Returns’ (2006)

Brandon Routh made his first and only appearance as Superman/Clark Kent opposite Kate Bosworth’s Lois Lane and Kevin Spacey’s Lex Luthor in director Bryan Singer’s Superman Returns, the first reboot of the Superman film franchise by Warner Bros.

ForbesJames Gunn Does Interview In Casket For ‘Grave Conversations’ Season 3By Tim Lammers

Superman Returns earned a 73% “fresh” rating from Rotten Tomatoes critics based on 275 reviews, while audiences gave the film a less-enthusiastic 60% “fresh” score on RT’s Popcornmeter based on 250,000-plus user ratings.

The RT Critics Consensus for Superman Returns reads, “Bryan Singer’s reverent and visually decadent adaptation gives the Man of Steel welcome emotional complexity. The result: a satisfying stick-to-your-ribs adaptation.”

‘Superman II’ (1980)

Superman: The Movie director Richard Donner returned but was fired and replaced by Richard Lester for the first sequel starring Christopher Reeve as the Man of Steel. Also returning from the original film was Margot Kidder as Lois Lane and Gene Hackman as Lex Luthor.

Superman II received an 88% “fresh” review from Rotten Tomatoes critics, while audiences gave it a 76% “fresh” Popcornmeter score based on 100,000-plus user ratings.

The RT Critics Consensus for Superman II reads, “The humor occasionally stumbles into slapstick territory, and the special effects are dated, but Superman II meets, if not exceeds, the standard set by its predecessor.”

‘Superman: The Movie’ (1978)

Christopher Reeve took up the mantle of playing Superman/Clark Kent following George Reeves’ turn as the iconic character on TV for Superman: The Movie. Directed by Richard Donner, Supeman: The Movie also starred Margot Kidder as Lois Lane and Gene Hackman as Lex Luthor, and featured The Godfather legend Marlon Brando in the small but pivotal role of Jor-El, the father of Superman, who was born Kal-El.

Superman: The Movie was largely a hit with Rotten Tomatoes critics, who collectively gave the film a 90% “fresh” rating based on 84 reviews. Audiences also were high on Superman: The Movie, giving it an 86% “fresh” Popcornmeter score based on 250,000-plus user ratings.

ForbesAmazon’s Early Prime Day Streaming Service Subscription Deals – What Separates Them From Bundling OptionsBy Tim Lammers

The RT Critics Consensus for Superman: The Movie reads, “Superman deftly blends humor and gravitas, taking advantage of the perfectly cast Christopher Reeve to craft a loving, nostalgic tribute to an American pop culture icon.”

James Gunn’s version of Superman will play in Thursday previews before opening in theaters nationwide on Friday. This article will be updated once RT posts its reviews for the movie.

ForbesWes Anderson’s ‘The Phoenician Scheme’ New On Streaming This WeekBy Tim Lammers