Yankees GM Cashman Remains Confident in Volpe Amidst Slump, Eyes Caballero as Potential Option
Bronx, NY – New York Yankees general Manager Brian Cashman publicly reaffirmed his faith in shortstop Anthony Volpe despite a challenging season at the plate, even as Jose Caballero emerges as a potential alternative. Cashman’s comments come as Volpe remains sidelined with a shoulder injury, receiving a cortisone shot on Tuesday and opening the door for Caballero to see increased playing time.
Volpe’s current full-season numbers are comparable to his .228/.288/.373 slash line over 1290 plate appearances in his first two Major League seasons, indicating his offensive struggles aren’t a new advancement for the 24-year-old. He debuted as the Yankees’ Opening Day shortstop in 2023, generating significant expectations, though the team has downplayed comparisons to Derek Jeter. The Yankees’ immediate placement of Volpe in an everyday role contrasts with their handling of other recent top prospects.
“We believe in Anthony,” Cashman stated, echoing a sentiment he’s maintained throughout Volpe’s tenure. Critics, though, may argue that continued confidence in Volpe hinders the Yankees from exploring upgrades at the position.
Cashman believes Volpe’s difficulties are linked to his shoulder injury and doesn’t anticipate a major roster change at this time. Volpe is entering arbitration eligibility this offseason,and his remaining three years of team control represent a valuable asset given the team’s high payroll and luxury tax concerns.Cashman hopes Volpe can develop into “a quality, above-average regular shortstop in the game.”
Though, the emergence of Jose caballero provides a potential alternative. Acquired from the Tampa Bay Rays at the trade deadline, Caballero has impressed with a .263/.358/.439 slash line in 68 plate appearances as a Yankee – his best offensive stretch in three MLB seasons. he’s demonstrated versatility, playing shortstop, both corner outfield positions, second base, and third base.
With Volpe out, Caballero has stepped into a regular role at shortstop. Manager Aaron Boone indicated the team will evaluate the situation when Volpe returns, suggesting a potential timeshare is under consideration.
The long-term outlook for Volpe’s shoulder remains uncertain. Cashman stated further testing is planned, and while offseason surgery hasn’t been ruled out, it’s not currently recommended. should surgery become necessary, Volpe coudl face a significant recovery period, potentially impacting his availability for a portion of the 2026 season and further solidifying Caballero’s role.