Swans Bid on Caylen Murray After Lions Fail to Match Under New Rules
“It was probably more, in the end, that they couldn’t match the bid.” Sydney list boss Chris Keane’s verdict to Fox Footy on Thursday night summed up the draft stunner of the year: the Swans bid on Brisbane academy prospect Caylen Murray at pick No.9, and the Lions fell three points short of matching under the AFL’s tightened rules.
The bid came moments after Brisbane traded down the second-round order with Port Adelaide, moving from No.20 in a deal that left the triple reigning premiers exposed if a Murray bid arrived early. It did. Per AFL, the Lions’ picks at No.24 and 25 were worth 1211 points against a 1626-point requirement once the 20 per cent grand finalist loading and maximum deficit were counted — a gap of three.
"I wouldn't be in the position I am today without them." New Swan Caylen Murray on how the Brisbane Academy has helped his journey.@Telstra | #AFLDraft pic.twitter.com/wnklA6DL7T
ESPN’s accounting shows why the maths mattered: new rules cap matching at two picks, a revised draft value index inflated the worth of top-10 selections, and the premier’s loading added 271 points to the bill. ESPN reports Murray is the earliest pick in draft history to have his club’s matching rights passed up.
Keane told Fox Footy the Swans ran the numbers and knew how tight Brisbane’s position was. “The rules changing and the ability to only match with a couple of picks these days versus multiple, previously, we were aware it was going to be pretty tight,” he said.
The Sydney Swans will enter the 2026 Telstra AFL Draft with a pick inside the top 10 for the first time since 2020 (pick 6). Here is a breakdown of how the draft works and the Swans' history when called to select at the national draft.https://t.co/VmzwaUCtvo
Murray stunned by the swoop
The 18-year-old half-back had met with Sydney twice — once by Zoom — and been given no hint of the play, AFL reported. He learned of the bid when the cameras found him at Marvel Stadium.
“I didn’t realise [the bid was in] until the camera was on me, which was a bit nerve wracking. I didn’t realise Brisbane couldn’t match, but I am stoked to be a Sydney Swans player,” Murray told AFL on Thursday night.”
He was quick to credit the academy that developed him over six years, including two seasons of VFL exposure. “I wouldn’t be in the position I am today without them,” he told Fox Sports. The Swans view the under-18 All-Australian as the long-term replacement for the departed Nick Blakey, having used the pick gained in that trade.
Essendon, Richmond and West Coast will all receive an early second-round pick as part of a Telstra AFL Draft rule change. Here's how the new draft compensation system works 👇@Telstra | #AFLDraft https://t.co/72LPY2fcsf
Lions undone by rules they forced
ESPN frames the irony plainly: Brisbane’s own manipulation of the old system drove the changes. In 2022 the Lions bundled picks 34, 35, 38, 40 and 41 to match Will Ashcroft’s bid at pick 2; in 2024 they used four picks for Levi Ashcroft at pick 5, and in 2025 three picks for Dan Annable at pick 6. The new two-pick cap and 20 per cent loading on bids matched by grand finalists closed those lanes.
The Lions had scrambled since the trade period to bank points and hoped a bid would come in the mid-teens, 7NEWS reported. Sydney’s pick, sourced from the Blakey deal, arrived three spots earlier than Brisbane could absorb.

The shockwave down the board
Brisbane’s loss rippled outward. Gustavo Teixeira, a genuine pick-one chance through the season, slid to St Kilda at No.11, and Collingwood landed its top target, mad Pies fan Sam Gayfer, as clubs without matching obligations moved up the order, ESPN reported. The Lions do hold three consecutive picks early in round two, at 27, 28 and 29.
Night one otherwise ran to script for club-tied talent. Carlton matched Richmond’s bid on father-son prospect Cody Walker at No.3, ending pre-draft fears under the new rules, the Sydney Morning Herald reported. Port Adelaide matched Essendon’s bid at No.1 for next generation academy player Dougie Cochrane, its first No.1 pick, and GWS took Ethan Matthews. Five Indigenous players went in the first round.
Flipping the script 🔃 New Swan Caylen Murray speaks to @JoshGabelich about Sydney's shock bid for the Brisbane Lions Academy product: https://t.co/TUfpQf68Vg@Telstra | #AFLDraft pic.twitter.com/49XbUkpNni
Round two resumes Friday at 7pm AEDT, with Port Adelaide holding picks 20 and 24 and Brisbane forced to wait until 27.
King’s road back stretches on
“He had a recent calf niggle, he is back into some running, I’m told, at Moorabbin. But at this stage, he is not scheduled to enter any of the main training drills with teammates until the Saints return from the holiday break,” Edmund said on SEN radio.”
The 26-year-old has played 84 games since St Kilda took him with pick 4 in the 2018 National Draft, and he is contracted on a long-term deal until 2032 — a commitment that puts the club’s medical and high-performance staff, and the sports medicine and rehabilitation specialists they work with, under sustained scrutiny as they manage his load back toward full training.
Everything you need to know ahead of the 2026 Telstra AFL Draft, including how to watch, how it works, matching bids, and more.https://t.co/F52HF4Aem9
For the Swans, the Murray heist lands a top-10 talent for a pick they effectively recycled, and list boss Keane made no apology for the play. “Whether that’s a good thing, or not, time will tell, I suppose,” he told Fox Footy. “But it’s certainly made the night very interesting.”
The club now known as the Sydney Swans traces its origins to 21 March 1873, when it was founded in South Melbourne as the South Melbourne Football Club, playing at Lakeside Oval in Albert Park. It adopted the Swan emblem in 1933, having previously been known as the “Bloods” for the red on players’ guernseys.
In 1982 it became the first professional Australian football club to permanently relocate interstate, moving from Victoria to New South Wales. The Swans have won five VFL/AFL premierships, including a 2005 title that ended a 72-year premiership drought — the longest in the competition’s history — before adding another in 2012, and have been the AFL’s most supported club for nineteen consecutive years dating back to 2006.
Disclaimer: The insights provided in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute medical advice or sports betting recommendations.