Student Column Cites Data Showing CS Unemployment Above English Rate
In a column published Wednesday, Washington University in St. Louis student Emily Loma argues that English majors face unfair career stigma, pointing to federal data showing computer science graduates actually post a higher unemployment rate than their humanities peers.
The piece ran November 19 in Student Life, the university’s independent student newspaper.
Loma, a contributing writer and English major, frames the column as a response to years of unsolicited career warnings. She writes that people who learn her degree often assume she will “end up being a barista at Starbucks,” a comment she says she has heard too many times to count.
The argument rests on a 2018 statistic from the National Center for Education Statistics that Loma cites. According to that data, the fields with the highest unemployment rates among college graduates were English language and literature and computer science — an outcome that cuts against the standard assumption about which degrees pay off in the labor market.
The numbers carry a comparison that Loma leans on. Computer science graduates earned higher median wages, yet their unemployment rate sat at 5.6%, above the 4.4% rate for English graduates, per the NCES figures she quotes.
The eight-year hold
The persistence of the gap is what sharpens her case. Loma notes that the computer science unemployment rate stayed at 5.6% across all eight years covered in the NCES study, while unemployment fell for most other fields of study over the same stretch.
She contrasts that with the reaction each group gets. In her telling, no one warns a computer science major that they will be permanently unemployed for choosing that degree, even though the federal data she cites shows both fields struggling at similar rates.
Loma traces the difference to an unspoken ranking. “They believe majors exist within a hierarchy, one with STEM at the top and English and fine arts at the bottom,” she writes, describing the assumptions behind the criticism she has received.
That hierarchy, she argues, perpetuates stereotypes about humanities graduates that the employment data does not support. Her column frames the barista joke not as harmless banter but as a belief system about which degrees deserve respect.
A wider job market problem
Loma also widens the frame beyond her own major. She writes that friends and family describe the job market as hard to break into for everyone, making employment difficult regardless of field of study — yet she says she has not heard anyone blame their unemployment on their degree.
The column lands amid a broader hiring slowdown that has touched white-collar recruiting across sectors, a context Loma invokes herself when she describes the market as difficult for graduates of every major. For students weighing fields against employability, the piece suggests the calculus is less clean than the STEM-versus-humanities shorthand implies.
Career offices and career coaching services that counsel graduates on translation of humanities skills into hiring pipelines have a stake in the debate, though Loma’s column does not name any provider — it stays a personal argument about stigma and data.
Her closing message is aimed at her peers. “For all my fellow English majors worrying about employment, you won’t be alone,” she writes, borrowing the NCES finding to make the point that the struggle crosses disciplinary lines.
Student Life publishes the column under its Short For(u)m Content series, a recurring first-person feature. The piece carries Loma’s byline as a contributing writer and reflects her own experience as an English major at the university.
The underlying NCES statistic dates to 2018, and the column does not update it with newer labor figures — the argument stands on the eight-year trend the study captured. Readers weighing the data should note that median earnings still favored computer science graduates in the same study, a fact Loma acknowledges in passing.
Loma’s column appears in a publication with long roots. Washington University in St. Louis was founded in 1853 by a group of St. Louis civic leaders concerned by the lack of institutions of higher learning in the Midwest, and it held its first classes in 1854 as a night school, tuition-free, with 270 students whose ages ranged from 8 to 46.
Originally called Eliot Seminary, it was renamed for George Washington and moved to its current campus in 1905, after its early buildings housed events tied to the 1904 Summer Olympics and World’s Fair.
What the column asks for is a change in how the criticism is distributed, not in the degrees themselves. As Loma puts it in the barista exchange she recounts: the warning never lands on the majors whose unemployment rates are actually highest.