Sonny Gray Returns to Minnesota Twins on Two-Year, $55 Million Contract
Sonny Gray agreed on Wednesday to a two-year, $55 million contract with the Minnesota Twins, RDS reported — a deal that came two weeks after the Boston Red Sox declined a $30 million option on him.
The 37-year-old right-hander gets an option year on the back end; FOX 9 reported the contract also includes an opt-out for the second season.
The arithmetic explains the move. Boston could have kept Gray at $30 million for one year and instead paid a $5 million buyout, RDS reported. Minnesota will pay him $55 million over two seasons — an average annual value of $27.5 million, close to what the Red Sox chose to walk away from, but spread across two years with a chance for Gray to reset his market at 38.
Gray had the power to force that Boston outcome himself. According to RDS, if the Red Sox had exercised the $30 million option, Gray could have triggered the same $5 million buyout. The option, in effect, protected him in both directions — which is what made the Twins’ new offer worth taking instead.
The contract brings Gray back to the franchise where he was at his best in recent memory. In two seasons with the Twins, 2022 and 2023, he went 16-13 over 56 starts with a 2.90 ERA and 300 strikeouts in 303 2/3 innings, per the team figures FOX 9 cited. His 2023 season ended with a second-place finish in American League Cy Young Award voting and an All-Star selection.

One year in Boston, 18 wins
The return follows the best season of that stretch. Pitching for Boston in 2026, Gray went 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA in 169 innings, leading the American League in wins, and finished fifth in AL Cy Young voting, RDS reported. He made 29 starts and struck out 149. He will enter his 15th major league season in Minnesota.
For Minnesota, the signing answers a problem that has shadowed the rotation since last spring. The Twins lost Pablo Lopez to a season-ending elbow injury on the first day of Spring Training in 2025, and Joe Ryan took over as the staff ace, FOX 9 reported. Gray, slotted at the front of a rotation, gives the club a proven second anchor.
FOX 9 framed the roster consequence plainly: Gray’s addition to the 2027 roster, if there is one, gives the Twins a strong front half of the starting rotation. That caveat is not rhetorical. According to FOX 9, the current collective bargaining agreement between Major League Baseball’s owners and the players’ association expires Dec. 1 — later this month — and a 2027 season is not yet guaranteed.
The frontier, then, is both contractual and calendar-based. Gray’s opt-out for the second season, per FOX 9’s report, means he controls whether the second year works for him or the Twins. Minnesota also brought back catcher Ryan Jeffers this week, who accepted the club’s qualifying offer worth a reported $23 million, the same outlet reported Tuesday.
A career rebuilt in the same places
Gray’s path has looped through two of the same employers now three- and four-times over. The Texas native was drafted 18th overall in 2011 by the Oakland Athletics and has since pitched for the St. Louis Cardinals, Cincinnati Reds and New York Yankees, RDS reported. His first Twins stint, from 2022 to 2023, was the best two-year run of that tour; the Red Sox declined to sustain it at $30 million a year.
What the Twins paid — $55 million over two years for a pitcher turning 38 during the deal — will read as a premium for a pitcher whose Boston season set his price. What Boston declined to pay was one guaranteed year at roughly the same annual value. The gap between those two decisions is the whole story of how Gray ended up back in Minneapolis.
For a franchise operating under the uncertainty of a labor deal that runs out Dec. 1, committing mid-range money to a 37-year-old rather than betting on prospects or prudence is a decision with its own risk profile. The opt-out gives both sides an exit if the calculation goes wrong.
When Gray debuted in 2013, contract structures like this one — short-term, high-average-value deals with opt-outs for aging starters — were the exception.
The Twins let him leave in free agency after 2023 and watched him lead the league in wins from Boston. Three years and one $5 million buyout later, they are paying $55 million to undo the mistake.
Disclaimer: The insights provided in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute medical advice or sports betting recommendations.