Should You Mask Up for Holiday Travel? Experts Weigh In on Flights, Airports and Best Masks
Millions of Americans preparing to travel for the holidays face decisions about whether to wear face masks as flu season starts early and measles outbreaks make the news, The Washington Post reported on Saturday.
The Tech TL;DR:
- Holiday travelers weigh mask protection against early flu season activity.
- Experts disagree on aircraft infection risks despite strong cabin filtration.
- NIOSH-approved N95s and KF94s offer high protection while surgical masks leak.
The United States has recently lost its measles-elimination status, adding urgency to travel safety discussions. While everyday masking is not mandatory for healthy people per the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, protective gear offers a safeguard for visiting vulnerable relatives, according to Jodie Guest, senior vice chair of epidemiology at Emory University’s Rollins School of Public Health.
“I want to be able to participate in the party and the family gatherings when I get there, and I want to keep everyone else there safe,” Guest told The Washington Post regarding her routine on long-haul flights.
Airplane Air Quality Debate
Experts hold differing views on viral transmission risks inside commercial aircraft cabins. Joseph Allen, a professor at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and director of its Healthy Buildings Program, downplays flight environments.
“I don’t wear a mask on an airplane,” he told The Washington Post. “I think this idea that airplanes are a high-risk environment is overstated.”
Allen notes that aircraft systems pull half their air from outside and filter the rest through high-efficiency particulate air filters capturing 99.97 percent of particles. Cabin air refreshes 20 to 30 times an hour, exceeding office building averages according to the CDC, yahoo.com reported.
Conversely, Anne Rimoin, associate dean for global health at the UCLA Fielding School of Public Health, still chooses to mask on flights during respiratory season. Cabin filtration cannot completely stop transmission when an infectious passenger sits nearby for hours, she told The Washington Post.
“It’s a really small inconvenience compared to losing several days of a trip due to any number of things that you can catch,” Rimoin said.
Airport Terminal Exposure Risks
Travelers encounter transmission threats beyond the aircraft cabin, particularly inside congested terminals. Guest describes airports as mass mixing events featuring reduced ventilation compared to modern planes.
Rimoin advises maintaining precautions throughout the entire journey, starting from local public transportation and continuing through boarding gates. Allen highlights boarding, deplaning, and deicing phases as higher-risk windows when active ventilation systems may be powered down.
Respirator Selection Criteria
Proper gear choice dictates filtration effectiveness against airborne particles. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health-approved N95 respirators filter at least 95 percent of airborne particles under standardized tests, featuring rigid cone shapes and dual head straps.
Alternatives include KN95 and KF94 options, which feature tent-like shapes that fit certain facial structures more comfortably. Experts advise discarding cloth coverings and surgical masks because loose edges allow unfiltered air leakage.
Travelers reusing older disposables should inspect elastic straps and nose foam for degradation after storage. Alongside respiratory gear, health authorities recommend staying current on flu, COVID-19, and RSV immunizations before departure.
Allen has studied airplane air quality for a decade and was a lead author of a 2013 National Academies report on infectious disease mitigation in airports and on airplanes. He holds a doctor of science in exposure assessment from Boston University and served as a scientific adviser to the White House from 2022 to 2024 and to the Massachusetts governor from 2021 to 2023.
“You don’t have to wear them everywhere all the time, but there are times when they can make really good sense, and that is particularly during respiratory virus season,” Rimoin said.