Rugby Concussion Lawsuit: Judges to Deliver Judgment This Year on Striking Out 378 Cases
Rugby’s concussion lawsuit took a decisive step toward resolution on Thursday as The Telegraph reported that Mr Justice Cotter and Senior Master Cook will deliver their judgment this year on whether 378 union cases should be struck out, after a two-day hearing at the Royal Courts of Justice ended without a ruling.
Claimants including World Cup winners Steve Thompson and Phil Vickery must now wait to learn whether the first batch of their cases survives, with The Telegraph understanding the verdict is likely to be appealed by whichever side loses.
The case has dragged through successive missed deadlines. Claimant counsel Paul Downes KC told the court that no material change had justified a further extension “two years, two weeks and five days” after the claimants missed their first deadline — a figure the defendants’ lawyers deployed to argue there was no legal basis for more time.
“When does this stop?”
The extensions argument landed hardest from the rugby authorities’ side of the room. William Audland KC, representing the Rugby Football League, pressed the point directly.
“When does this stop?”
— William Audland KC, counsel for the Rugby Football League, per The Telegraph
William Audland KC, representing the Rugby Football League, said there never seemed to be an end to the problem because of the mess the claimants got themselves into in the first place.
He said that millions of pounds had been spent and wasted, asked again “when does this stop?”, and questioned if the court would say “no” at this juncture. He also said that the next deadline “will come and go and there will be some form of non-compliance”.

36 diagnosis letters in three years
Downes KC revealed that the claimants — who include dozens of rugby league players alongside the union cases — have secured medical letters of diagnosis from just 36 players in the union case, The Telegraph reported. He argued that “more has been achieved in 99 days than in the previous three years” in supplying medical documentation since KP Law took over the case, and asked for an extension through January.
KP Law, which owns the claim and is itself owned by Asertis, the litigation funder that underwrote the original firm Rylands Garth’s work, said it inherited the case “blind” to what it called the “impenetrable chaos” left behind.
Downes claimed Rylands Garth had left the case in a “shambolic” state and that Richard Boardman, the solicitor removed from the record in August, failed to co-operate in transferring the medical files unless he was paid.
The defendants disagreed with that framing. Nina Goolamali KC, representing World Rugby, showed the court that Leigh Day — which has acted as consultants to the case since February 2026 — estimated it would take four months of due diligence to understand the complexities of the case, and declined to take it on.
Michael Kent KC, representing the Rugby Football Union, offered his own reading of why KP Law ended up holding the brief.
“This may be a situation where Asertis and KP Law having run out of options because they couldn’t get Leigh Day to come on board, decided, ‘Well, let’s have one last throw of the dice’ and bring on our ‘in-house’ team,”
— Michael Kent KC, counsel for the Rugby Football Union, per The Telegraph
October 2028 trial “impossible”
KP Law is targeting an October 2028 trial date, but the rugby authorities’ legal teams dismissed that timetable as “impossible”, The Telegraph reported. For hundreds of former players — the class includes World Cup winners and dozens of league players tracing brain injuries to head impacts sustained during careers — the exhibition of delay has real cost.
The Telegraph Sport revealed last week that Boardman is being sued by his own barrister, who has accused him of improperly making payments to his wife — an allegation that remains contested and untested.
The Rugby Football League, now a co-defendant with the Rugby Football Union, was itself born of a split from that body.
Founded in 1895 as the Northern Rugby Football Union after 22 clubs resigned from the RFU, it adopted its present name in 1922 and remains the governing body for rugby league in England, organising the professional competitions and the community game while administering the England national team. Its innovations have shaped the sport: it introduced the six-tackle rule in 1971 and created the World Club Challenge in 1976.
For the defendants — the RFU, World Rugby and the Rugby Football League among them — millions of pounds have been spent and wasted on the case, and the judges’ verdict is likely to be appealed by the losing side. The ruling is expected by the end of December, The Telegraph reports, with either side expected to challenge it immediately.