Researchers: Dropping Degree Rules Linked to $4,600 Pay Gain for Non-College Workers
Researchers from the University of Kentucky, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and MIT found that U.S. employers cut degree requirements in more than 10% of job postings between 2011 and 2021, and that non-college workers hired into those roles earned roughly $4,600 more annually than peers in jobs that never required a degree.
The Tech TL;DR:
- Degree requirements dropped over 10% across 446,500 tracked job starts from 2011 to 2021.
- Non-college hires in “decredentialed” roles gained a persistent $4,600 annual wage premium.
- Non-college hiring rose only 1.2 percentage points despite requirement removal.
Matching postings to administrative records
The study, published October 26 in Nature Human Behaviour, linked Lightcast job-advertisement data to U.S. Census Bureau employment records covering approximately 446,500 job starts. “Matching job postings to 446,500 job starts in U.S. administrative data from 2011 to 2021, we show that employers reduced the share of postings requiring a degree by more than 10%,” wrote Thomas Lyttelton, Dylan K. Nelson and Nathan Wilmers in the paper.
Phys.org reported the team used this matched dataset to compare earnings trajectories for workers without four-year degrees who entered occupations that dropped requirements versus those that never had them.
Wage premium persists for five years
Workers without bachelor’s degrees hired into positions that removed degree requirements earned approximately $4,600 more per year than comparable workers hired into jobs that never required a degree, according to the researchers. That advantage appeared to persist for at least five years post-hire. The same cohort was more likely to be Black, Hispanic or women than the workers they replaced, Phys.org reported, citing the study’s demographic breakdown.

Hiring behavior lags policy change
Despite the requirement reductions, actual hiring of non-college workers barely moved. “Yet most employers that drop requirements do not hire non-college workers (non-college hiring rises 1.2 percentage points; 95% confidence interval, (0.5, 2.0)),” the authors wrote.
Phys.org noted the researchers concluded that “decredentialing is a promising tool for social mobility, but only when employers follow through.” EngineeringNews.net, briefing the same findings, emphasized that the wage gains materialized even though the share of non-college hires increased only marginally.
Employer cost savings documented
The paper also identified a direct financial incentive for firms. “Employers also benefit, as removing degree requirements reduces labor costs,” Lyttelton, Nelson and Wilmers wrote. The mechanism appears to be access to a broader candidate pool willing to accept market-rate compensation for skills rather than credential signals, though the study did not isolate the specific cost-reduction channels.
The University of Kentucky, founded in 1865 as the Agricultural and Mechanical College of Kentucky under the Morrill Land-Grant Act, is the state’s largest public university by enrollment with 35,952 students as of fall 2024.
It is classified as an R1 institution with very high research activity, spending $476.5 million on research and development in 2022. The university operates seven libraries, including the William T. Young Library, a federal depository, and hosts the Linguistic Atlas Project, an archive of American English dialect survey materials.
Next research phase targets compliance
The authors indicated future work will examine why requirement changes fail to translate into hiring changes at scale. The DOI record for the study (10.1038/s41562-026-02610-5) lists the publication date as October 26, 2026, placing the findings in the current academic cycle for labor-economics review.