Referee Jeroen Manschot Criticized for Handball Penalty in NEC vs PSV Match
Referee Jeroen Manschot sparked a firestorm of criticism on Sunday after awarding a contentious penalty during NEC’s 4-1 defeat to PSV.
The decision, centered on a deflection off Deveron Fonville, has reignited the debate over the application of the handball rule in the Eredivisie.
The incident, which saw the ball strike the underside of Fonville’s elbow while held against his body, was analyzed during the Goedemorgen Eredivisie program on ESPN. Pundit Bram van Polen expressed total confusion regarding the current officiating standards.
“What can you possibly do about this? It hits the underside of his elbow, and he keeps his elbow against his body too. There’s nothing you can do about this, is there? I don’t think this is a penalty in any way.”
— Bram van Polen, pundit.
The controversy centers on the inconsistency of handball rulings despite previous guidance from Raymond van Meenen, the head of refereeing. Van Meenen had previously clarified that defenders are not required to keep their arms behind their backs during natural running movements. Van Polen said that the situation has only deteriorated since that explanation, pointing to similar incidents occurring in recent matches, including an RKC fixture.
“Surely we don’t want this any more? I really thought we’d moved on from that. Since Raymond van Meenen gave that explanation, it only seems to have got worse.”
— Bram van Polen, pundit.
Hans Kraay junior also weighed in on the performance of Jeroen Manschot, who served as the match referee. Kraay suggested that Manschot, despite being considered a top Video Assistant Referee, should have exercised more discretion when reviewing the footage.
“When he went to the screen, he could simply have said: ‘Don’t call me over for this nonsense again’.”
— Hans Kraay junior, reporter.
Jeroen Manschot began his officiating journey with the KNVB in 2000, eventually making his Eredivisie debut in 2014. His professional development has been bolstered by advanced training, including a 2026 participation in the Centre of Refereeing Excellence, a UEFA program designed for officials aiming to manage international matches. This rigorous preparation complements his extensive experience across multiple Dutch leagues.
Within the football community, Manschot is recognized as a top Video Assistant Referee, a status that draws heightened scrutiny when his on-field decisions spark controversy. While he is noted for his commitment to personal development and self-criticism, critics argue that his application of technology during high-pressure Eredivisie fixtures sometimes lacks the necessary discretion, prompting calls for officials to exercise greater restraint when reviewing subjective handball incidents.
Van Polen concluded his critique with a blunt message for officials working in the VAR booth: “Just leave it alone if you’re the VAR.” The confusion was echoed by presenter Milan van Dongen, who said that the football community remains uncertain about whether defenders should be keeping their hands behind their backs or playing naturally.