Portugal Supreme Court Upholds 14-Year, 9-Month Sentence for Taxi Driver Who Killed Student in Crosswalk
Portugal’s Supreme Court upheld a 14-year, nine-month prison sentence for a taxi driver who killed a university student in a Lisbon crosswalk last September, rejecting an appeal that sought to cut the term by four years.
The 3rd Criminal Section of the Supreme Court of Justice (STJ) dismissed the driver’s challenge to the homicide conviction with eventual intent and the combined sentence, ruling part of the appeal inadmissible on the dangerous driving charge, Jornal de Notícias reported. The decision, issued November 18, leaves intact the heaviest penalty handed down in December 2025 by the Lisbon Central Criminal Court.
Abel Xavier Franco, the driver, entered the left-turn lane on Avenida dos Estados Unidos da América against a red light while other vehicles were stopped, striking Afonso Gonçalves, 21, who was crossing with a green pedestrian signal, according to facts established at trial. Franco drove on without stopping to help; Gonçalves died hours later at São José Hospital.
“Elevated requirements of general prevention in the face of urban road accidents and the vulnerability of pedestrians.”
the justices wrote in their ruling, noting the crimes occurred months after Franco had been released on parole.

The Lisbon court had imposed 12 years for homicide with eventual intent, two years and nine months for dangerous driving, and one year and nine months for failure to render assistance. The combined sentence of 14 years and nine months sits just above the midpoint of the legal range for cumulative penalties, which spans a minimum of 12 years to a maximum of 16 years and six months, the STJ panel observed.
Franco’s defense had asked the Supreme Court to reduce the homicide term to nine years and six months and the single combined sentence to 10 years and six months. The court also rejected a nullity claim arguing the trial court omitted a ruling on a personality assessment.
At the time of the fatal crash on September 8, 2024, Franco was on conditional release from a previous sentence. He had been involved in at least three prior hit-and-run incidents, one of them also fatal, 24 Notícias reported, citing the trial record. The Supreme Court emphasized this history in upholding the sentence.
Beyond imprisonment, Franco was stripped of his driving license for five years and barred from working as a taxi driver for eight years, both periods to begin after the prison term is served. The court also ordered payment of approximately 233,000 euros in damages to the victim’s family, to be covered by the insurer, according to 24 Notícias and PressNET.
The Supreme Court of Justice (STJ), created by the Constitution of 1822 and installed eleven years later, is Portugal’s highest court of law aside from the Constitutional Court. It replaced the kingdom’s ancient higher courts — the Board of Conscience and Orders, the Desembargo of the Palace, and the Council of State — and its judges inherited the title of counselors from those bodies.
“The penalty fixed respects the legal criteria,” the STJ conselheiros concluded in the November 18 acórdão.
Related reading
- ARD Alpha Broadcast ‘Stark Durch Bindung’ Highlights Child Overload and Empathy
- NATO Fighter Jets Scrambled in Estonia; Finland Restricts Flights, Shipping
- Portugal Navy Infantry Ends Lithuania Rotation with Memorial Cross (newsy-today.com)
- RBA's Fifth Hike Adds About A$94 a Month on A$600,000; Three Voted to Hold (daybreakwire.com)