Plummer, Minn., Man, 62, Dies After Electric Scooter Collides With Pickup on Highway 59
A 62-year-old Plummer man died Monday evening when his electric scooter collided with a pickup truck on U.S. Highway 59 in Plummer, Minnesota.
The Minnesota State Patrol identified the victim as Ernest Joseph Shimpa, the Grand Forks Herald reported.
The crash happened at 6:18 p.m. on Monday, November 16, at the intersection of U.S. Highway 59 and Central Avenue East, a stretch of road in Red Lake County southeast of Thief River Falls.
State Troopers say Shimpa’s Currie electric scooter was traveling northbound on Highway 59 when it struck a 2015 Chevrolet Silverado. The pickup was facing west, attempting to enter the highway from a business driveway. The driver, 71-year-old Donald John Hagen of Plummer, wore his seat belt and was not injured. Alcohol is not suspected as a factor, and the road was dry at the time.
What remains unexplained is the sequence that brought the two vehicles together. The State Patrol has released no further details about the exact circumstances of the collision, and the crash remains under investigation.
Who responded at the scene
Four agencies assisted the State Patrol in Red Lake County: the Red Lake County Sheriff’s Office, the Plummer Fire Department, Sanford Ambulance and Oklee Ambulance.
A second scooter death one day earlier
The Plummer fatality came one day after another deadly collision between a car and an electric scooter in the region. A Colorado man died on Sunday, November 15, in Aberdeen, South Dakota, when a 2017 Nissan Titan traveling eastbound on 8th Avenue Northwest struck his scooter near Shortridge Drive, according to KELO’s reporting of preliminary information from the South Dakota Highway Patrol.

| Detail | Plummer, Minn. | Aberdeen, S.D. |
|---|---|---|
| Date | Monday, Nov. 16, 6:18 p.m. | Sunday, Nov. 15 |
| Scooter rider | 62, died | Colorado man, died |
| Other vehicle | 2015 Chevrolet Silverado | 2017 Nissan Titan |
| Other driver hurt? | No | No |
| Status | Under investigation | Preliminary, under investigation |
What the research shows
Fatal collisions between electric scooters and motor vehicles have drawn research attention in recent years. A study published by ScienceDirect examined 17 rented dockless e-scooter fatalities involving motor vehicles in the United States during 2018 and 2019, and found that 82% of those fatal collisions occurred at night.
The same study found fatalities involving an e-scooter or another personal conveyance were more likely than pedestrian fatalities to involve being struck in a crosswalk. That dataset covers rented dockless scooters specifically, and should not be read as a trend that applies to every e-scooter crash, including the one in Plummer, where the rider was on a personal Currie scooter.
Still, the findings give context to a pair of back-to-back deaths in the Upper Midwest. Both crashes involved scooters and larger vehicles on public roads; neither has been tied publicly to darkness or crosswalks, and neither investigation has reached conclusions.
Where the investigations stand
The Minnesota State Patrol has not said whether either driver will face charges, and it has not released the point of impact, speeds or sight lines at the Highway 59 and Central Avenue East intersection. The Grand Forks Herald reported that authorities withheld the victim’s identity until 6 p.m. Tuesday, November 17, before confirming Shimpa’s name.
The Aberdeen investigation, run by the South Dakota Highway Patrol, remains in its preliminary stages as well.
What is not yet known
Neither agency has explained how the scooters and the vehicles came into contact, whether speed or visibility played a role, or whether either driver will be cited. Hoodline’s reporting notes there are no further details on the exact circumstances that led to the Plummer collision.
The question that opened this crash file stays open: how a northbound scooter and a west-facing pickup, on a dry road with no alcohol suspected, ended up in the same point of space on Highway 59.