Panel Discusses Historical Freedom in Ēķis Film “The Dark Border
A five-member panel including director Andrejs Ēķis met this week to ask how freely a screenwriter may bend historical facts, taking Ēķis’s spy thriller “Tumšā robeža” (“The Dark Border”) as its case study.
The recording is now available via LSM.
The session is part of "Kritikas grieznes," a discussion series about how Latvian cinema is watched, analysed and judged, LSM reported. Alongside Ēķis, the panel brought together film scholar Inga Pērkone, theatre scholar and critic Līga Ulberte, collective-memory and communication Vita Zelče, and poet and critic Aivars Madris, with film director Ieva Ozoliņa moderating, according to LSM.
Why one thriller became the test case
The panel’s stated questions cut to the core of the genre-film debate: how historical feature films shape collective memory, how genre cinema builds audiences’ picture of Latvia’s past, whether a viewer can tell a historical fact from artistic interpretation, and how much liberty a director may take with documented history in a screenplay.
“Tumšā robeža” was chosen as the research example precisely because it sits on that fault line — a spy thriller set in 1938 Riga, on the eve of the pact that would hand Latvia to Soviet occupation.
That setting is what makes the discussion timely. The film dramatises a period Latvian cinema has rarely touched, and its premiere drew praise from figures who lived through the era’s long shadow — while at least one prominent reviewer has questioned whether the film’s history was ever meant to be believed at all.
The invented meeting that divides reviewers
The sharpest public criticism has come from DELFI, whose review singles out the film’s “diplomatic fantasy” — a staged 1938 meeting in Riga between German and Soviet envoys, passing a secret message from Hitler to Stalin.
The reviewer concedes that secret contacts between dictatorships are not impossible and that cinema need not become a history-book reconstruction, but argues that the known chronology of German–Soviet rapprochement, culminating in the Molotov–Ribbentrop pact of August 1939, makes the episode at least debatable.
Why Riga? Why in that form? The film, the review says, offers too few convincing answers, leaving the viewer to accept the construction simply to keep following the plot.
From there, the DELFI review lands on a framing the panel’s central question makes newly relevant: perhaps “Tumšā robeža” was never aiming at a credible portrait of 1938 Latvia, but simply using history as a grateful backdrop for an adventure film. On that reading it is effectively B-grade genre cinema — a label the reviewer insists is no insult, pointing to the many enjoyable low-budget spy and adventure films worldwide whose makers never claimed deep historical revelation.
The review also faults the film’s human texture: the characters rarely step outside their functions, and the potential romance between the White figure’s daughter and the forester’s daughter is cut off in a dead end. A more colourful, eccentric cast of types, the reviewer suggests, would have served the film better than a roomful of grim faces in a seemingly momentous geopolitical conspiracy.
Ēķis’s history with history
Ēķis arrives at this debate with a track record of turning Latvian history into popular entertainment. As DELFI notes, he worked as a producer alongside director Aigars Grauba to bring Latvian audiences their own historical box-office hits, starting with “Baigu vasara” (2000) and “Rīgas sargi” (2007), later adding “Sapņu komanda 1935” (2012) and “Nameja gredzens” (2018).
What unites those films, per the same account, is the drive to turn well-known Latvian events into popular spectacle — grand adventures, big heroes and no less grand sets. “Tumšā robeža” continues that line, but in a less-documented corner of the past, where the facts are thinner and the room for interpretation wider.
Where the film does have documented weight, its characters carry it. DELFI’s review notes that the 1938 political reality was not merely a backdrop for shootouts: the protagonist Vitolds’s actions are driven by exile experience, complicated relations with British intelligence and fear for relatives in occupied Latvia.
The supporting figures Yuriy Dyakonov, played by Rubenis, and Leon, played by Daiņš Grūbe, are described as far more contradictory than the hero, adding human complexity to the story — a dimension the review finds largely missing from the finished film.
What the premiere audience said
The film’s premise itself has a stated origin. According to Santa.lv, the idea belongs to actor Jēkabs Reinis, who happened upon a book bearing the same title, and who plays the double lead role of counterintelligence officer Balts and journalist Ilmārs Blanka. Reinis’s performance drew appreciation not only from film professionals but from retired general Raimonds Graube, Santa.lv reported.
Actor Ivars Kalniņš, attending the premiere with his wife Laura, told the magazine Privātā Dzīve that he and she agreed the leads — Reinis, Vilis Daudziņš and Elizabete Milta — played superbly.
“The film depicts a less-researched time,” Kalniņš told Privātā Dzīve. “I think many back then had a presentiment about the Molotov–Ribbentrop paper being signed, and the world was preparing for the big war. It’s a pity it’s all talked about so late, but now we should be examining our own times more, not just last century’s events.”
The question the panel left open
The discussion, as LSM frames it, did not settle the matter it convened to weigh. Whether audiences can separate a documented fact from an artistic interpretation — and whether a director is accountable for the difference when the film titles itself with Latvia’s darkest border — remains the live question the series was built to keep asking.
His partnership with director Aigars Grauba on historical fare began with “Baiga vasara” (2000), which Ēķis produced and co-wrote, and continued through “Rīgas sargi” (2007), “Sapņu komanda 1935” (2012) and “Nameja gredzens” (2018). He returned to directing himself in the mid-2010s with comedies, adapting his film “Svingeri” for audiences in Ukraine, Estonia, Norway, Russia and Poland.
What is not yet known, from any of the three reports, is whether “Kritikas grieznes” will take up the question again — or which film the series will pick apart next. The recording of the full discussion is available through LSM.