Pak Climate Minister Ties Indus Treaty Talks to India Invite, Avoids Past Threat
Pakistan’s climate minister said Sunday he would discuss the suspended Indus Waters Treaty only if India extends a formal invitation for bilateral talks, avoiding direct answers about his past threat to “cut off that hand” which takes Pakistan’s water share.
- Musadik Masood Malik conditioned talks on a formal Indian invitation during the SCO forum in New Delhi on Nov. 22.
- India placed the 1960 treaty in abeyance after the April 22, 2025 Pahalgam attack that killed 26 people.
- MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal reiterated Friday that India’s position on the treaty remains unchanged.
- Malik’s visit is the first by a Pakistani federal minister to India in three years.
Minister ties dialogue to formal invitation
Asked about his June remark warning Pakistan would “cut off that hand” which attempted to take away its water share, Malik repeated that he would answer bilateral questions only after a formal dialogue begins.
But first, you must extend that invitation. Malik also stated he had not been called for bilateral talks even once during his visit. “I have not been called for bilateral talks even once. Without a mechanism, how can we discuss bilateral issues?” he said.

India holds firm on treaty stance
The Ministry of External Affairs said Friday its position on the treaty has not shifted. “As far as the IWT is concerned, we have made our position very clear and that is where it remains. There is absolutely no change,” spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said, according to The New Indian Express.
India placed the 1960 agreement in abeyance following the April 22, 2025 terror attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir, in which 26 people were killed. New Delhi has said the suspension will continue until Pakistan credibly and irrevocably abjures support for cross-border terrorism.
Malik presses for structured terrorism dialogue
Malik told reporters India and Pakistan should establish a mechanism to exchange evidence on terrorism, saying Islamabad had proposed handling the matter bilaterally or multilaterally. “You bring your evidence, and we will bring ours,” he said, according to Hindustan Times and The SBharat. He added that discussions would happen only if the goal was a lasting solution rather than provocation.
He also stated Pakistan had suffered casualties from terrorism and argued that structured talks were necessary for meaningful progress, The SBharat reported. India has consistently maintained that normalisation depends on credible action against cross-border terrorism.

India approves Taj Mahal visit, rejects dargah request
Security agencies and the Ministry of External Affairs cleared Malik’s request to visit the Taj Mahal in Agra but turned down his request to visit the Nizamuddin Dargah in Delhi, Hindustan Times reported. The rejection was confirmed by ANI on Saturday.
Rare ministerial visit amid freeze
Malik led Pakistan’s delegation at the three-day SCO forum from Nov. 20 to 22, marking the first visit by a Pakistani federal minister to India in three years, Hindustan Times reported. India had invited all SCO member states, including Pakistan, to the multilateral event. The minister also called for a structured mechanism to exchange evidence on terrorism.
“We have stated on many occasions, in various forums, that evidence can be presented bilaterally. We have also suggested that this could be handled multilaterally. His request to visit the Taj Mahal in Agra was approved, while a request to visit the Nizamuddin Dargah in Delhi was rejected by security agencies and the MEA.”
Musadik Masood Malik entered federal politics as Minister for Water and Power in the caretaker cabinet of Prime Minister Mir Hazar Khan Khoso from April to June 2013. He later joined the Pakistan Muslim League (N), serving as spokesperson for Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif from November 2014 and as Special Assistant to Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi on Media Affairs from August 2017, holding federal minister status in Abbasi’s cabinet from April 2018.
Malik was elected Senator from Punjab on a general seat in March 2018 with PML-N backing and won re-election on a technocrat seat in April 2024 with 121 votes.
“Whenever you talk of peace and when different countries come together and they sit together and make efforts to take forward peace and security, then we will also participate fully,” Malik said on the sidelines of the SCO event in Delhi.
Speaking about his visit being the first by a Pakistani minister in three years, Malik said he hoped such visits would continue. “Mujhe ummeed hai ki dobara aap gila nahi karenge aur hamara aana jaana rahega…(I hope you won’t have any more complaints, and that we’ll continue to visit each other),” he told news agency ANI.