National Heritage Committee Rejects Preservation Plan for Seun District 4 Site Near Jongmyo
The National Heritage Committee has halted the Seun District 4 redevelopment project in Seoul, voting unanimously on November 18 to reject a preservation plan for archaeological remains discovered at the site.
Committee Rejects Excavation Preservation Plan
The rejection by the National Heritage Administration’s burial heritage subcommittee came after nine attending members reached a consensus.
The committee concluded that the proposal submitted by the Seoul Housing and Communities Corporation (SH) failed to meet requirements for preserving historical remains in their original locations and did not adequately reflect the site’s cultural identity, as reported by Hankyoreh. The ruling prohibits any construction that would alter the site until a new preservation plan is submitted and approved.
The remains, including remnants of Joseon-era defensive entrance gates known as imun, building foundations, and drainage systems, were identified during preliminary excavations between 2022 and 2024. SH had initially submitted a preservation proposal in January 2024, which was deferred.
After a 31-month interval, a revised plan was submitted this August, suggesting the relocation of artifacts and the creation of a cultural heritage plaza in a basement level, a proposal the committee ultimately rejected following four previous deferrals. The committee said that the proposal failed to incorporate the historical urban structure of the Hanyangdoseong fortress wall area.

Seoul City Denounces Administrative Stance
Seoul City officials expressed strong opposition to the ruling, characterizing the committee’s decision as an act of administrative overreach. Spokesperson Ho Joon-seok stated in a November 20 press release that the administration views the move as violent, noting that the National Heritage Administration had previously designated the remains for relocation and preservation, only to shift its requirement to “in-situ preservation” in October, Yonhap News reported.
Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon previously criticized the committee during a city council session on November 18, accusing the body of delaying the project through repeated deferrals.
The city argues that it had complied with earlier directives to confirm the project’s business plan, which received approval from the Jongno District Office on June 19. “The city is forced to suspect that this is intended to obstruct the Seun District 4 development in connection with the Jongmyo issue,” the city’s statement read.
Officials highlighted that the project has been delayed for over two decades, imposing a monthly interest burden of approximately 1.4 billion won on residents. The city further argued that requiring a World Heritage Impact Assessment (HIA) in this context violates the principle of prohibition of improper association under the Administrative Framework Act.
Heritage Committee Defends Regulatory Principles
In response to the criticism, members of the National Heritage Committee issued a statement on November 20 clarifying that the “in-situ preservation” principle does not require leaving all remnants exactly where they were found.
Instead, the committee emphasized that core remains currently in temporary storage should be restored to their original locations following development to maintain the historical urban structure. Committee members asserted that Seoul City has misunderstood and misrepresented the intent of the deliberations.
National Heritage Administration Chief Hur Min added via social media that the project’s scope was significantly altered in October 2025, when the city increased the maximum building height for the area to 145 meters, according to 한겨레.
Hur said that the revised preservation plan submitted by the construction side in August was insufficient relative to the increased scale of the development. The dispute remains unresolved, with both the city and local residents considering legal action to contest the decision, according to reports from Chosun Ilbo.
Impact on Future Development and Legal Recourse
The stalemate leaves the scheduled March 2027 start date for construction in doubt. Developers and local stakeholders are now evaluating their next steps, which may involve administrative litigation to challenge the committee’s authority.

As the conflict between the city’s development goals and national heritage preservation standards intensifies, residents continue to bear the financial costs of the stalled progress. “The administrative consistency and trust have collapsed, and the principles of transparency have been destroyed,” the city said in its formal response to the committee’s decision.
Meanwhile, local residents have held forums expressing concern that World Heritage registration could act as a new regulation on their property rights and living environment, with some calling for the withdrawal of the registration application.
Seun District 4 is situated directly in front of the Jongmyo Shrine, a location that has become a focal point for debates regarding urban development and historical preservation. The site contains remnants of Joseon-era village gates, known as ri-mun, as well as significant drainage systems from the same historical period.
The project at Seun District 4 covers 32,000 square meters opposite the Jongmyo Shrine, with plans for buildings up to 142 meters, a major increase from the 71.9-meter limit set in 2018.