MLB: 1719 Potatoes, 1961 UFO Tale Inspire Fisher Cats’ Space Potatoes ID
The New Hampshire Space Potatoes, the Fisher Cats’ alternate identity played across nine home games over the past two seasons, mashes two strands of state history: the first white potatoes grown in North America, planted in Derry in 1719, and the country’s first widely reported alien abduction, alleged to have happened near Lincoln in 1961. MLB reported the origin story this week.
The Double-A affiliate of the Toronto Blue Jays has spent two seasons moonlighting as the Space Potatoes, and the name’s roots run deeper than a marketing meeting. MLB’s report traces the branding to a pair of New Hampshire stories — one documented, one disputed — that the team’s front office fused into a single, deliberately odd identity.
Where did “Space Potatoes” come from?
The potato half is settled history. In 1719, Scots-Irish settlers planted the first white potatoes grown in North America on land in the present-day town of Derry. In 2013, fourth graders from the Derry Village School successfully lobbied to make the white potato the official state vegetable, according to MLB.
The space half comes from a spot about 80 miles north-northwest of the Fisher Cats’ ballpark in Manchester — the site where, in 1961, the first widely reported alien abduction in American history allegedly took place.
“So, you mash those two together, you get the Space Potatoes,” Fisher Cats assistant GM Andrew Marais said.
What happened in New Hampshire in 1961?
MLB’s account centers on Betty and Barney Hill, an interracial couple who both worked as civil servants and, the report stresses, never sought media attention. The details of what they described emerged largely after they underwent hypnotic regression therapy years after the incident, MLB reported.
In their account, the Hills pulled off the highway onto a small rural road and encountered beings who encouraged them to leave their car. They were brought aboard a craft, separated, examined and questioned.

One detail has become the story’s most retold moment.
“At one point they come into Betty’s room,” Clair said, “and start pulling on her teeth and saying, ‘Why aren’t your teeth coming out? Why are Barney’s teeth coming out?’ (They didn’t say his name.) And she said, ‘He has dentures. It happens when you get older.’ They didn’t understand age. They asked her multiple times, ‘What is older?’ She had to explain human aging to them.”
Clair also described the couple’s recollection of the beings themselves.
“They also both remember grey-faced creatures with a larger skull … [a] forehead that gets narrower below with almost no nose and a flat mouth. That is the common depiction of what is commonly known as ‘greys,’ grey aliens.”
Is there any proof it happened?
No. Both outlets treat the incident as an allegation, not a fact. MLB frames it as the first widely reported alien abduction in American history — a claim about fame, not confirmation. usubjects.com, covering the same story, is more explicit: no definitive explanation has established that any object was extraterrestrial, and explanations have ranged from misidentified aircraft to astronomical phenomena.
usubjects.com also connects the case to Exeter and to witnesses including resident Norman Muscarello and local law-enforcement officers, describing a large, brightly illuminated object seen by multiple observers — including a police officer, which the outlet says lent the story enduring credibility among UFO enthusiasts.
That is a different thread from the Hills’ account MLB reported: the Exeter case is a sighting, the Hills’ story is an alleged abduction. The outlets do not reconcile the two, and neither claims to.
Clair’s position, as MLB reported it, is that the Hills’ accounts — and how those accounts became public — are worth considering, without endorsing them as fact.
What did the team make of it?
The branding arrived before the backstory, at least for one pitcher. Austin Cates, the Blue Jays’ No. 30 prospect and a Nevada native, learned the specifics of the Hill incident only a couple of months after he had already pitched as a Space Potato, MLB reported.
He had long been open to the possibility that Area 51 holds proof of extraterrestrial life, and hearing that the Hills first reported their experience only to the government convinced him.
“That’s crazy!” he said. “Yeah. Aliens are real. I’ll throw it out there. I’ll say they’re real.”
Fans have made the identity their own. Before the game on Sept. 18, 2026, a regular named Jake waited in line at the gates to receive a Trey Yesevage-Space Potatoes bobblehead.
Jake said that if somebody says it happened, more than likely there is some truth to it.
Why does an alternate identity matter to a Double-A team?
Alternate identities have become a familiar part of Minor League Baseball, as usubjects.com notes: teams adopt temporary names, logos and uniforms that reflect regional culture or invite fan participation. In New Hampshire’s case, the outlet writes, the concept turns a decades-old unexplained sighting into accessible entertainment — less a claim about alien visitation than a humorous celebration of one of the state’s most recognizable oddities.
The Fisher Cats have leaned in. The Space Potatoes identity covered nine home games across the past two seasons, per MLB, complete with themed merchandise like the September bobblehead giveaway.
Marais, like many Space Potatoes fans, is a UFO believer, MLB reported. Every year when he drives an hour into the White Mountains, he stops at an alien-themed gas station and passes a roadside marker in the town of Lincoln.
GM Fisher sees attendance boost from Space Potatoes identity
General manager Taylor Fisher, who joined the Fisher Cats in 2024 and found “Space Potatoes” written on a white board on his first day, sees an upside even in a visit from the source material.
“It would boost attendance,” Fisher said, “and that’s what matters. Butts in seats.”
He no longer needs the white board explained. As of November 2026, Fisher and baseball fans across New England know exactly what the phrase means — and the next bobblehead line at Delta Dental Stadium will tell anyone who doesn’t.