Mina Sinui‘s Brother and Husband Embroiled in Dispute, Leading to Theory‘s Collapse
Seoul, South Korea – October 6, 2025 – A public disagreement between Mina Sinui (Park Soo-ji) and her husband, Ryu Philip, has triggered the dismantling of a popular fan theory surrounding the singer’s career trajectory. The conflict, unfolding online, centers on accusations leveled by Philip regarding the origins of a widely circulated narrative about Sinui’s success, a theory he attributes to his sister-in-law.
The escalating tension began with Philip’s posts alleging that the theory-which posited a purposeful, orchestrated rise to fame for Sinui-was fabricated and actively promoted by Sinui’s brother. He claims the narrative was constructed to benefit Sinui’s public image, and expressed frustration that the false account had gained significant traction. Philip’s statements,initially veiled,became more direct,culminating in a post stating,”Thanks to them,” implying duty for the misleading information. The fallout has prompted widespread discussion among fans and a swift retraction of support for the theory.
The disputed theory centered on the idea that Sinui’s early career was strategically managed, with deliberate leaks and manufactured controversies designed to generate publicity. While the specifics varied, the core claim suggested a level of manipulation beyond typical promotional efforts. Sinui has not directly addressed the accusations, leaving fans to interpret the situation and reassess their understanding of her career.The incident highlights the complex relationship between artists, their families, and the often-speculative world of fan theories. The future impact on Sinui’s public perception remains to be seen.
