Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert is facing scrutiny regarding his status as an elite NFL player, with analyst Nick Wright publicly stating Herbert has “never been elite.” The assessment, made on the “First Things First” program, has sparked debate as the Chargers navigate the offseason following a wild-card playoff exit.
The discussion around Herbert’s performance comes as the Chargers prioritize his protection. General Manager Joe Hortiz recently emphasized the importance of bolstering the offensive line and adding players to support Herbert, according to a statement reported by the team’s website.
Despite the criticism, Herbert has received support from teammates. Wide receiver Ladd McConkey believes Herbert deserves consideration in the MVP conversation, stating, “I’m telling you, he’s a stud. I don’t understand what else he needs to do. He’s out there balling,” in an interview with Fox News Digital. McConkey acknowledged Herbert’s reluctance to self-promote, noting the quarterback “would never say it.”
Herbert completed the 2025 season with 3,727 passing yards, 26 touchdowns, and 13 interceptions, according to FOX Sports data. His girlfriend, Madison Beer, has publicly expressed her desire to start a family, adding a personal dimension to the ongoing narrative surrounding the quarterback.
The Chargers’ offseason has also included a controversial coaching decision, signing the brother of a star player as a running back coach, a move that drew criticism from some NFL fans online. The team is attempting to rebuild after a disappointing playoff run, with Herbert remaining central to their plans.
The debate over Herbert’s elite status continues, with some questioning his overall impact despite statistically strong seasons. The Chargers’ performance in the upcoming 2026 season will likely be pivotal in resolving the discussion.
