Job Seekers in the United Kingdom Face a Persistent “Wall of Silence”
Job seekers in the United Kingdom face a persistent “wall of silence” as employers increasingly fail to acknowledge applications, a trend known as job ghosting that has drawn scrutiny from government-backed reviews.
The practice, which leaves candidates without status updates or interview feedback, is complicating labor market entry for young workers and prompting calls for mandatory transparency from major firms.
Former minister Alan Milburn highlighted the issue in a major review released this week, which focuses on young people not in employment, education, or training, known as NEETs. Milburn proposed that large employers provide “meaningful feedback” to all unsuccessful applicants under the age of 25. The goal is to reduce the proportion of NEETs from 13% to 5% by 2036, according to the report.
The Human and Economic Cost of Silence
For graduates, the lack of communication causes serious psychological and professional harm. Yugraj Samrai, 23, from Coventry, told BBC News that he has submitted hundreds of applications since July. He receives no response in 30% to 40% of cases, noting that the silence makes him “feel like a statistic, not a person.”
“I understand there are very few graduate jobs available, but at least give me a response to say whether I'll progress onto the next stage or not.” Yugraj Samrai, 23, from Coventry, told BBC News.

Ffion Johns, 24, from Llanelli, echoed these frustrations after applying to 70 roles before securing an interview in September. She told BBC News that the inability to obtain feedback makes it difficult to refine her approach for subsequent applications. Research from head-hunting firm Robert Walters previously found that 86% of UK job seekers have experienced a total lack of response from hiring organizations, BBC News reported.
The absence of communication creates a barrier to professional development, as candidates cannot identify which skills or resume adjustments are required to become competitive. Jessica Anderson, 21, from Swindon, noted the heavy time and emotional investment required to tailor applications, which she feels goes unrecognized when firms fail to send even automated rejections.
Operational Constraints and Potential Solutions
Employers often cite the high volume of applications as a primary barrier to providing individualized feedback. Meg Burton, a career coach based in Leeds, suggested that while providing detailed critiques for every applicant may be impractical, firms should at least provide timely notifications of rejection. She told BBC News that artificial intelligence could assist companies in managing these communications more effectively.
The government may eventually adopt the Milburn proposals to mandate feedback, though some observers raise concerns about the potential impact of receiving a high volume of formal rejections. Ellie McCrone, 20, from Northampton, argued that transparency remains essential, as “you can’t fix something unless you know what the problem is.”
Alan Milburn, who was born in 1958, served as the Member of Parliament for Darlington from 1992 to 2010. During his parliamentary career, he held several senior government roles, including Chief Secretary to the Treasury and Secretary of State for Health. Before entering national politics, he worked as a coordinator for a trade union studies unit and served as a business development officer for a local council.
Beyond his ministerial experience, Milburn has a long history of involvement in social policy and education. He served as the chair of the Social Mobility Commission from 2012 to 2017 and has held the position of Chancellor of Lancaster University since 2015.
For now, job seekers are advised to move away from high-volume, generic applications. Burton recommended that candidates focus on tailoring their CVs to specific roles rather than submitting hundreds of identical applications. “Not hearing back doesn’t mean you aren’t a great candidate,” she told BBC News. “Put it down to experience and move on.”