Jared Padalecki’s Guarding Stars Hits No. 1 Worldwide on Netflix, Critics Give 92% on Rotten Tomatoes
Jared Padalecki's holiday romantic comedy Guarding Stars hit No. 1 worldwide on Netflix Wednesday as critics gave it a 92% Rotten Tomatoes score.
Streaming globally on Netflix since its debut on Wednesday the holiday romantic comedy Guarding Stars has climbed to the No. 1 viewing position in the platform’s worldwide top ten, according to FlixPatrol data reported by MovieWeb.
The 107-minute film pairs Leighton Meester with Jared Padalecki in a fake-dating holiday story adapted from Katherine Center’s 2022 novel The Bodyguard. The project was developed under the novel’s title before changing to avoid confusion with Kevin Costner’s 1992 film, MovieWeb noted.
She's hired to keep a charming action star safe. Keeping her feelings out of it? That's the tricky part. Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki star in GUARDING STARS, now playing on Netflix. pic.twitter.com/bbnJlCSWwF
Rotten Tomatoes Records and Reviews
The feature marks Padalecki’s return to live-action film roles after a seventeen-year hiatus following the 2009 Friday the 13th reboot, and critics have responded with a 92% approval score on Rotten Tomatoes.
“Guarding Stars does everything it’s supposed to do and does it well,” critics from TheWrap wrote. Decider characterized the feature as a “pleasantly cheesy movie that will likely satisfy anyone who enjoys a good ol’ holiday rom-com.”
Audience and Critical Response
Following the release of the trailer, viewers took to social media to share their excitement about seeing Leighton Meester on screen again, with one commenter writing that they were seated for the actress as Gossip Girl’s Blair Waldorf. Reviewers on Rotten Tomatoes also shared positive feedback as audience scores climbed alongside the critical rating.
Among the commentary, Declan said that Guarding Stars is better than the typical streaming Christmas movie despite its shortcomings being numerous and obvious. Meanwhile, viewers highlighted the emotional impact of the story, with one audience member noting that the film delivers a mix of laughter, genuine tears, and pure joy from start to finish.

Director and Production Insights
Director Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum praised the lead actors for possessing a rare quality that makes audiences feel like they already know them while still being able to completely surprise people. Screenwriters Richard Keith and Erin Cardillo worked alongside Gina Matthews and Grant Scharbo to adapt the story while keeping the spirit of Katherine Center’s novel intact.
During production on the Montana ranch, Leighton Meester faced freezing temperatures while wearing multiple layers of clothing and pants for every scene. Co-writer Richard Keith explained that although specific backstory details from the book regarding the mother were omitted from the dialogue, they still informed how Hannah behaves and who she is as a person.
Cast Preparation and Production Background
To prepare for her role as bodyguard Hannah Brooks protecting movie star Jack Stapleton, Meester learned stunt work, horse riding, and firearms handling, Who What Wear reported. “In every scene, you have to understand, I was wearing at least four pairs of pants, all layered on top of one another, and then multiple pairs of socks,” Meester told ELLE regarding the Montana ranch shoot.
During his seventeen-year hiatus from live-action feature films, Jared Padalecki maintained a prolific television career. He notably starred as Sam Winchester in the dark fantasy series Supernatural for fifteen seasons between 2005 and 2020. Following this long-running role, he transitioned to the title character in the action crime drama series Walker, which aired for four seasons from 2021 to 2024.
The script was co-written by Richard Keith, Erin Cardillo, Gina Matthews, and Grant Scharbo, with Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum directing. “We could use a Christmas classic this year,” Meester told ELLE.
Jared Padalecki and Leighton Meester star in Netflix’s new 107-minute Christmas rom-com Guarding Stars, premiering November 18. https://t.co/WLzW689DMM pic.twitter.com/bqcbjppX3H