Italy’s Top Court Upholds Life Sentence for Ex-Virtus Doctor Who Poisoned Wife and Mother-in-Law
The trial has ended where it began: with a life sentence.
Italy’s Supreme Court of Cassation confirmed the life sentence of Giampaolo Amato, the former Virtus doctor and ophthalmologist convicted of killing his wife and mother-in-law with a mixture of drugs in 2021, making the penalty final after it was imposed in the first two degrees of judgment. The first penal section of the high court handed down its decision after nearly seven hours of deliberation.
- The Court of Cassation rejected the defense appeal, ending the case after life sentences in both earlier trials.
- Prosecutors said Amato poisoned his wife and mother-in-law with a drug mixture including Sevoflurane and Midazolam in 2021.
- Judges identified a dual motive: a relationship with a younger woman and access to his wife’s estate.
- The couple’s son, also a doctor, maintains his father is innocent and says direct evidence is missing.
Seven hours behind closed doors
The Supreme Court judges did not rule quickly. After almost seven hours in chambers, they sided with the Attorney General’s request to reject the appeal filed by Amato’s lawyers, Franco Coppi and Valerio Spigarelli, and reaffirmed the defendant’s full criminal responsibility.
During the closing arguments, deputy prosecutor Simone Perelli called the appealed judgment “unattackable.” “The judges on the merits have ascertained the defendant’s criminal responsibility beyond every reasonable doubt,” he said.
Amato has been in prison since 2023. He has always denied the central accusation: that he poisoned his wife Isabella Linsalata and her mother Giulia Tateo with a mixture of drugs, using Sevoflurane and Midazolam, as the prosecution charged, according to Sky.

The son’s last appeal to innocence
On the eve of the Cassation hearing, Amato’s son Nicola — himself a physician — defended his father in an interview with the daily la Repubblica. “He is innocent” because “direct evidence is lacking and the case cannot be closed.” He added that he and his sister “were not subjected to the father’s influence.”
Prosecutors saw something else entirely. According to the account of the charges, Amato perhaps wanted to commit “the perfect crime” to “close his past, eliminating anyone who could have represented an obstacle.”
Prosecutors outline dual motive for killing
The motive, prosecutors said, was twofold. On one side stood the desire to freely pursue a relationship with a younger woman. On the other, the financial interest tied to taking possession of his wife’s properties.
First-degree judges reasoned that her death before the civil formalities of the marriage expired would serve a double aim: it would safeguard Amato’s relationship with his children, spare him blame for the marriage’s breakdown, and let him keep his legitimate-heir share of a substantial estate.
The first person to suspect anything was Isabella’s sister, Anna Maria Linsalata, who joined the case as a civil party, assisted by attorney Maurizio Merlini, according to Ansa.
Ten days, two deaths
- Oct. 9, 2021: Giulia Tateo, 87, is found dead.
- Night of Oct. 30-31, 2021: Isabella Linsalata, 62, a gynecologist, dies.
- 2023: Amato is detained in prison.
The appeal court’s harsh reasoning
The judges of the Bologna Assize Court of Appeal, in the grounds of their ruling, described a killing driven entirely by selfish motives. The pair faced what they called “a reiterated murder dictated exclusively by selfish motivations, defining a personality trait lacking any humanly or ethically comprehensible profile.”
Two lives were taken, the ruling said, through conduct that was “not only premeditated, but also coldly and lucidly executed with methods of great cunning.”
The appeal judges called the body of circumstantial evidence against Amato “granitico.” On the motive, they echoed the first-degree ruling at every point.
Virtus is best known to most readers as the name of Bologna’s storied basketball club, of which Amato was the long-serving doctor. Founded in 1927, the Black V is the oldest club in Italian basketball and the second most titled in the country after Olimpia Milano, with 17 national championships, 8 Italian Cups and two EuroLeagues to its name.
Where the case stands now
With the final rejection of the appeal, the appellate judgment — branded “unattackable” by the prosecution — carries definitive force. Nicola Amato publicly insists the opposite: that the case, in his words, “cannot be closed.” The two positions now stand split between a finalized verdict and a family’s last objection.