Indiana Libertarians Fall Just Short of 2% Threshold for Automatic Ballot Access
Lauri Shillings finished 253 votes short of the 2% threshold that keeps the Indiana Libertarian Party on ballots automatically, preliminary returns from all 92 counties show, closing out a 32-year run of automatic ballot access as a new minor party wins its place.
Shillings drew 38,663 votes in the Nov. 3 secretary of state race — 1.987% of the 1,945,765 ballots recorded so far, Indiana Capital Chronicle reported. The 2% threshold at that total is 38,916 votes.
Former Indianapolis Mayor Greg Ballard, running for the Lincoln Party, received 70,068 votes, or 3.60%. If the preliminary results hold, the Lincoln Party gains the convention-nomination option Libertarians would lose, Indiana Capital Chronicle reported.
The numbers could still move. Counties had until Tuesday to certify returns, but the Indiana Election Division gives them until Friday to make corrections. Party chair Stephanie Dasbach said Libertarians are waiting for certified results before deciding anything.
“We cannot know anything until the final certified results are out,” Dasbach told Indiana Capital Chronicle. “We will pursue any avenues we can to ensure that every vote is counted and that the election is secure.”
Indiana Capital Chronicle reported that Dasbach left open whether the party might pursue a recount or take legal action should Shillings come up short. Dasbach said the party will help its 2028 candidates gather signatures if needed.
What the 2% buys
Indiana lets a minor party whose secretary of state candidate wins at least 2% but less than 10% nominate candidates by convention, under rules the state’s candidate guide spells out. Candidates who miss the mark must petition onto the ballot, with signature requirements tied to 2% of the most recent secretary of state vote in each district they seek to represent.

The Libertarian Party of Indiana has held ballot access since 1994. Dasbach said the party expected Shillings to clear the bar, and that Shillings was “largely locked out of the media coverage given to her three opponents” yet still drew more than 38,000 votes.
“Obviously, our expectations were to reach the 2% ballot threshold, but this was a uniquely challenging race and environment this season,” Dasbach said.
The Libertarian Party of Indiana is weighing its options while counties have until Friday to make corrections to their certified returns — a process that could matter in a race where Shillings sits just 253 votes short of the 2% threshold.
How the race unfolded
In the preliminary tally, Democrat Beau Bayh took the secretary of state contest, earning 1,007,815 votes, or 51.8%. Republican Max Engling received 829,083 votes, or 42.6%. Nearly 6% of Hoosiers backed a minor-party candidate in the race.
University of Indianapolis political science professor Laura Merrifield Wilson pointed to two factors working against Shillings: a competitive major-party race and a second alternative on the ballot. Ballard, a former Republican, may have drawn moderate Republicans looking for an option outside their party’s nominee, she said.

“Of course, if they’re able to clinch the 2%, then the conversation is moot,” Wilson said. “But that said, this would be I think a major loss for the party.”
About one in three of his votes came from Marion and Hamilton counties, which together cast about one in five votes in the race. He drew 5.9% in Marion County and 5.3% in Hamilton County, against 3.6% statewide. Shillings topped 2% in 62 of Indiana’s 92 counties, according to preliminary precinct returns.
Ball State University political science associate professor Chad Kinsella said it is hard to know where Ballard’s voters would have gone without him on the ballot.
“I think there’s a group of people out there that are disaffected,” Kinsella said. “And I have a feeling that this election, it was a lot of Republicans that were very happy to go for any third party because they were really angry with their party.”
A record year for early ballots
The Nov. 3 election drew nearly 2 million Hoosiers, about 42% of registered voters, up from about 40% in the 2022 midterms, according to preliminary returns from the state. Turnout stayed well below the last two presidential elections, when about 65% of registered voters cast ballots in 2020 and 62% in 2024.
Nearly 45% of ballots were cast absentee — which in Indiana covers both in-person early voting and mail ballots — up from about 37% four years earlier. This year’s absentee total came to 892,609, close to 204,000 above what the 2022 report showed, while Election Day voting dropped from roughly 1.2 million to roughly 1.1 million.
| Measure | 2022 | 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Ballots cast | 1,881,560 | 1,997,142 |
| Turnout | 39.5% | 41.9% |
| Absentee share | About 37% | Nearly 45% |
Kinsella said the shift in voting method stood out more than the turnout rise, and he expects more voters to use absentee options over time. Wilson said competitive races give voters more reason to show up, and that growth in early voting “certainly speaks to voter enthusiasm.”
Marion County saw ballot totals climb by nearly 38,000 over 2022, as turnout moved from 34% to 41%. Hamilton County turnout rose from 48% to 52%, and Monroe County jumped from 41% to 47%. In Johnson County, turnout held at about 39% but the absentee share climbed from 47% to 55%.
What losing access would mean
Wilson said losing automatic access would change where the party puts its time and money ahead of the next election.
“Now they’re going to have to look at candidate recruitment probably a little bit differently, at the political infrastructure for campaigns a little differently,” Wilson said.
Whatever the final count shows, Dasbach said the party anticipates shifting its approach to recruiting and backing candidates and members. The next secretary of state race, in 2030, offers another shot at automatic access.
The Libertarian Party of Indiana traces its origins to July 14, 1974, when about 20 to 25 people met at a hotel near what is now the Indianapolis International Airport and voted to start the party.
It first secured ballot access in 1994, when Steve Dillon topped 2% in the secretary of state race — the very contest that now determines its status. Its best statewide showing came in 2020, when gubernatorial nominee Donald Rainwater drew 11.44% of the vote, finishing second in one-third of the state’s 92 counties.
For now, the margin sits at 253 votes with corrections due Friday.