India Votes Against UN Moratorium on Death Penalty at General Assembly
India voted against a United Nations resolution calling for a global moratorium on the death penalty at the General Assembly’s Third Committee on Friday, siding with 32 other countries against the measure.
The resolution, which urges countries to move toward abolishing capital punishment, passed with 133 votes in favor, 33 against and 16 abstentions, according to a report in The Times of India. India’s vote continues a pattern: New Delhi opposed similar resolutions in 2016, 2018 and 2024. The United States also voted no, telling the committee that decisions on capital punishment belong to domestic democratic processes.
Bhavika Mangalanandan, first secretary at India’s Permanent Mission to the UN, defended the vote in remarks to the committee. “There is no international consensus against capital punishment, and article six of the ICCPR permits its use with restrictions,” she said, according to The Times of India, citing ANI. “Capital punishment is meted out after rigorous and due legal process.”
The vote lands at a moment when India’s own death row is growing. The country held 574 prisoners under sentence of death on December 31, 2025, its highest count since 2016, driven by trial court rulings, The Hindu reported in an editorial published on November 18.
An argument over two resolutions
India’s objections went beyond the moratorium itself. In a separate resolution on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, New Delhi disassociated itself from a paragraph that linked the death penalty with torture and ill-treatment, while backing the rest of the text. Mangalanandan objected to discussing lawful executions alongside unlawful killings, calling the approach “disingenuous and mischievous.” It sought, she said, to present “personal ideological preferences as settled international law.”

“Extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions are unlawful and a clear violation of human rights,” she said, adding that India supported the broader resolution seeking to eradicate such violations.
The United States, in comments quoted by The Times of India, took a parallel line. Yaryna Ferencevych, deputy representative to the UN Economic and Social Council, said Washington did not consider the lawful use of capital punishment inconsistent with respect for human rights. France welcomed the resolution’s adoption as a step toward universal abolition.
How the committee split
| Position on the moratorium resolution | Countries |
|---|---|
| In favor | 133 |
| Against | 33 |
| Abstaining | 16 |
The “rarest of rare” defense
India’s case for keeping the penalty rests on judicial safeguards. Under Indian law, capital sentences may be imposed only in the “rarest of rare” cases, and a sessions court’s death sentence must be confirmed by a High Court before it stands. Mangalanandan also cited the presumption of innocence and mandatory consideration of mitigating circumstances, per The Times of India.
The Hindu’s editorial contests that defense in practice. While India last executed anyone in 2020 — the convicts in the Delhi gang rape and murder case — Parliament has expanded the number of capital offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, the criminal code that replaced colonial-era statutes.
The editorial characterizes the expansion as penal populism: a response to public outrage, especially over sexual violence, that leaves untouched the poor policing and low conviction rates it identifies as the real obstacles to deterrence.

The research record offers deterrence arguments little comfort: studies cited in the editorial have failed to find evidence that the death penalty deters more effectively than life imprisonment.
What the death row numbers show
Project 39A, a research program on capital sentencing, has tracked how those safeguards perform for the people they are meant to protect. The Supreme Court released 38 people from death row between 2016 and 2025, by which point they had spent an average of eight years under sentence. Some had endured more than two decades.
The safeguards, The Hindu argues, neither block convictions resting on flawed evidence or false testimony nor remedy unequal access to competent legal representation.
India’s distinction between judicial executions and extrajudicial killings is legally sound, the editorial concedes. Its claim that due process reliably protects people facing execution is less so. The paper points to the 2015 Law Commission report headed by Justice A.P. Shah, which found the death penalty “fails to achieve any constitutionally valid penological goals” and recommended abolishing it for every crime except terrorism and waging war.
The case for narrowing the penalty
Only a small group of countries worldwide now carry out more executions than India, The Hindu reports. The editorial’s prescriptions follow the Law Commission’s logic: suspend executions formally, commission a review of the penalty statutes and of how death row prisoners are treated, and exempt offences that do not involve intentional killing.
On that last point, the editorial cites research warning of a perverse effect — excessively harsh punishment for non-fatal crimes can push offenders to escalate, including killing potential witnesses.
The Committee’s resolution now heads toward the full General Assembly, after India was among 33 countries that voted against it while 133 supported the proposal and 16 abstained. India, for the fourth time in a decade, has signaled its own: “It is therefore a travesty to term it state-inflicted death,” Mangalanandan told the committee.