India Drop Siraj, Jadeja for Wellington Test; Kotak Defends XI After Day One
Mohammed Siraj, India’s leading wicket-taker in the current World Test Championship cycle, was left out of the XI for the opening Test against New Zealand in Wellington on Thursday, November 19 — and batting coach Sitanshu Kotak insisted the call was right. India went with four seamers, none of them Siraj, and by stumps the decision was under strain after Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips dragged New Zealand from 70 for 5 to an unbroken 173-run sixth-wicket stand.
When Shubman Gill and Tom Latham exchanged team sheets at the Basin Reserve before the toss, neither Siraj nor Ravindra Jadeja appeared. India instead picked Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna alongside Jasprit Bumrah, with Washington Sundar preferred to Jadeja as the spin-bowling all-rounder. Both omitted players later appeared as substitute fielders.
The morning vindicated the seamers. New Zealand slumped to 70 for 5 on a grass-covered pitch. Then the sun came out, the surface dried, and India’s attack — outside Bumrah — could not find a way through.
Kotak backs the call
Seven of the twelve questions at the post-play media conference were about the two exclusions. Kotak, who does not sit in the group that picks the XI, defended the combination anyway.
“There is nothing wrong [with Siraj]. I mean I can’t see anything wrong,” Kotak told reporters after the opening day’s play in Wellington. “That’s the best possible XI the team management thought and that is the one which played [this game].”
He pointed to the mix of skills in the chosen attack. “Two seam the ball well, two swing the ball well,” he said, adding that a taller bowler gives extra bounce on a damp, grassy surface and that a selection must be made “for all four or five days.”
Siraj’s numbers sit beside his omission
The case for Siraj is not small. He took 43 wickets in 11 matches in the ongoing World Test Championship cycle. Across 23 Tests in Australia, South Africa and England, he has 95 wickets.
Cricbuzz reported his tour of Sri Lanka in August brought four wickets in two Tests — and, more tellingly, speeds well below his usual mark. He appeared in rhythm during India A’s four-day match against New Zealand A last month. Kotak downplayed Sri Lanka as a factor: “Sri Lanka, obviously it was different conditions, and Siraj played both the Tests there.”
Asked whether India had got it wrong in hindsight, Kotak disagreed, while still calling Siraj a “world-class bowler.”
Why Washington over Jadeja
The Jadeja call raised as many eyebrows. Kotak explained it through New Zealand’s line-up.
“Because there are four left-handers, an offspinner was picked. Not only the first innings, there’s the second innings too. So keeping all that in mind, the decision was made… And he [Washington] can also bat well. Jaddu is obviously an unbelievable all-rounder, he has done so well,” he said.
Turning to an off-spinner in pace-friendly conditions casts doubt on the faith in the pace battery — and why, if batting depth drove the call, one of the best performers with the bat in challenging conditions was left out. Jadeja holds the second-best batting average in SENA countries since 2021 behind Rishabh Pant.
A pitch that flattened faster than planned
Kotak admitted the surface surprised everyone. “It was a sunny day, the weather was good, so it dried out quicker than even the curator would have thought,” he said. “Nobody can control that.”
He also flagged the Kookaburra ball — a point Gill had made two days before the Test. “After 30-35 overs when the ball gets old, the seam of the Kookaburra ball flattens,” Kotak said. With little help from the old ball, India’s bowlers other than Bumrah lost their incision, and Kotak conceded the less experienced pacers could have used the stumps more against Phillips, who dominated through the off side.
Bumrah, at the other end, was a class apart. “Not only with his line length, the amount of movement he gets, and the way the ball talks, that skill he has,” Kotak said, calling the spearhead a learning reference for the younger bowlers.
What the second morning holds
India enter day two with the second new ball only two overs old and New Zealand’s total still under control. Kotak’s arithmetic was blunt: two more wickets in the morning session and the hosts could have been dismissed quickly. Keeping New Zealand under 300 is the target.
The Basin Reserve, two kilometres south of the Wellington city centre at the foot of Mount Victoria, is the oldest first-class cricket ground in New Zealand and the only cricket ground to hold listed status with Heritage New Zealand.
Its origins were accidental: an 1855 earthquake uplifted a swampy basin by nearly 1.8 metres, draining land that had once been earmarked as a shipping canal, and prisoners from Mount Cook Gaol began levelling it for a cricket ground in 1863. The first game was played on 11 January 1868, and the ground today doubles as a busy traffic roundabout, with the New Zealand Cricket Museum housed in its Museum Grandstand.
For now, the selection debate will keep running. Siraj’s 95 wickets in 23 Tests in Australia, South Africa and England remain on the table, and the management’s “best possible XI” must prove itself over the remaining days of this Test.