Hundreds Protest Nathan Cofnas DEI Talk at Oxford’s Oriel College
Hundreds of protesters filled the streets around Oriel College, Oxford, on Tuesday evening to oppose a talk by Nathan Cofnas, the American academic who raised plagiarism accusations against the late Cambridge professor Jason Arday.
The event, titled “An Evening with Nathan Cofnas: Is DEI Undermining Higher Education?”, was organised by Oxford’s Reform UK student society. Oriel College allowed the society to use a lecture theatre and declined to cancel the booking, saying it had a “statutory duty” to uphold freedom of speech within the law. About 40 people made it inside, with less than a third of the space filled, The Guardian reported.
Protesters block the entrances
Crowds sought to block the college’s main entrances, chanting “Say his name – professor Jason Arday” and carrying signs reading “Remember professor Jason Arday”, The Guardian reported. Chants of “Nathan Cofnas: shut him down!” were also heard, according to The Telegraph, which reported that protesters held signs saying “Nathan Cofnas not welcome” and “Jason Arday, rest in power”.
Police appeared towards the end of the event to clear protesters from the entrances.
Frank Zona, a PhD student studying for a term at Oxford, told The Telegraph he was prevented from entering by the crowd.
“I tried to walk through them. It was a large crowd, and eventually they started pushing me back,” Zona said.
“It certainly felt like there was a mob tonight which prevented any sort of protection of free speech or debate. And I think that’s a very dangerous thing.”
He criticised the policing, telling The Telegraph that officers arrived “completely underprepared” and were “outmanned” until reinforcements brought the gate presence to about 15.
Protesters trying to bust through a door to enter Oriel College. pic.twitter.com/ERQcx7JxsN
Arday’s death hangs over the event
Cofnas wrote a blog in July accusing Arday, a Cambridge professor of sociology of education and the university’s youngest Black professor, of plagiarism in his doctoral thesis and questioning his biographical claims. Arday denied the allegations but acknowledged errors in his work, according to Al Jazeera. He resigned his post and was found dead at his home in south London on August 14, at the age of 41. An inquest is under way into his death, the Oxford Mail reported.
Inside the lecture theatre, Cofnas was asked if he wanted to apologise to Arday’s family but declined, saying the implication of the question was that “we shouldn’t criticise powerful figures”.
He added: “I would ask the people at Cambridge University who protected him for three years, who suppressed all criticism … I would ask them these questions,” drawing brief applause, The Guardian reported.
Cofnas spent most of the hour discussing what he called the “race equality thesis”. He has previously written that black people would “disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment” under a meritocratic system, and has tied race to intelligence in writing that led to his dismissal from a position at Emmanuel College, Cambridge, Al Jazeera reported.
He was suspended as a postdoctoral researcher at Ghent University in August after making the allegations against Arday, and was later allowed to resume some academic work remotely without teaching while an investigation continued. The Oxford Mail reported he was reinstated after pressure from US ambassador Bill White.
Students and politicians oppose the visit
Anneliese Dodds, the MP for Oxford East, said she had written to Oriel College after constituents raised concerns.
“Cofnas’ views are both repellent and contrary to the facts,” Dodds said. “I have written to Oriel College to ask what they are doing to act on students’ concerns about this meeting, including on safety grounds.”
An online petition demanding the university “cancel Nathan Cofnas’s invitation to speak” had more than 32,000 signatures by Tuesday, Al Jazeera reported. It said: “Ideas platformed at Oxford do not stay in the lecture theatre.” An earlier open letter counted by The Voice Online had reached nearly 30,000 signatures, supported by the Oxford Students’ Coalition Against Racism, Black Lives Matter, EveryDay Racism and Stand Up to Racism.
Forty-nine fellows and members of Oriel’s Senior Common Room signed a statement, reported by The Voice Online, calling Cofnas’s claims about race and intelligence “racist, abhorrent and without scientific foundation”.
Students at the protest voiced distress at the university’s decision. A course administrator who did not want to be named told the BBC: “I’ve seen a lot of students of colour are feeling unwelcome, uncomfortable, frightened by the fact that Oriel and the wider university has not shut this down.”
One protesting student, a first-year studying English and German who declined to be named, told The Guardian: “I think Oxford and Cambridge, as two academic institutions, should be working together to banish this from ever happening again. And the fact that we can’t even act as the example, I think, makes me almost ashamed to be a part of this.”
Tommy, a second-year maths student, told The Guardian the event followed a pattern: “There was Tommy Robinson and the Oxford Union, and obviously there were protests for that as well. So I think it’s quite a nasty pattern that we’re seeing with these Oxford societies pandering to the far right.”
The photographer Misan Harriman, former chair of trustees of the Southbank Centre, attended the protest because of concerns about Cofnas’s “damaging” rhetoric.
“The university has failed all the students, not just the black students, by having them see this as something that could be remotely seen as part of the course of free speech,” Harriman said.
Hannah, a first-year law student, told The Guardian: “Even if Oxford won’t listen to us and won’t cancel the event, we’re still going to show up and we’re going to show that we won’t let that decision silence us.”

Oriel stands firm on free speech
The college said in a statement: “Oriel College is committed to upholding freedom of speech within the law and has a statutory duty to do so. This includes the freedom to express views that many find deeply offensive.” Oxford University said hosting the event “does not imply endorsement by the College of the views of its speakers”.
At an extraordinary meeting of the Students’ Union on November 11, Oriel’s Provost, Lord Mendoza, confirmed the event would go ahead, Oxford’s student paper Cherwell reported. The Proctors’ Office Clerk, Gillian Hamnett, said society events are not approved in advance and can be cancelled only pending a risk assessment of whether they are “safe and lawful”, and confirmed that the Proctors’ security officers would attend.
The Free Speech Union encouraged members to email the college congratulating it for “standing firm”, Cherwell reported.
Days before the talk, campaign group Led By Donkeys placed a Ku Klux Klan hood and a sign reading “racists welcome here” on Oriel’s statue of Cecil Rhodes, The Independent reported.
The right-wing commentator Thomas Moffitt, known as “Young Bob”, was photographed in Oxford with a desk sign reading “D.E.I murdered Jason Arday – changed my mind”, the Oxford Mail reported.
An inquest into Arday’s death remains under way.