How Anthony Ippolito Landed ‘I Play Rocky’ With a Basement Tape and Ended the Stallone Search
Anthony Ippolito landed the role of Sylvester Stallone in Peter Farrelly’s “I Play Rocky” by sending an unsolicited audition tape, filmed in his grandmother’s 1970s-era basement, to casting director Rick Montgomery. The tape ended the planned worldwide search on the spot, and the 27-year-old is now predicted to get a Golden Globe nomination.
Farrelly, the two-time Oscar winner behind “Green Book,” handed Montgomery a one-line brief: “Go find Stallone.” The film, which got a limited theatrical release on Friday, dramatizes how an unknown Stallone wrote “Rocky” in a three-day burst and refused to sell the screenplay unless he could star in it.
Casting the man who refused to be recast was the project’s first real test, and the way it was solved now reads like a mirror of the story itself.
A cold tape ended the search
Montgomery, who had cast Farrelly’s “Green Book,” “There’s Something About Mary” and “Dumb and Dumber,” began work about a year before production, sending Peter Gamble’s script to agents and meeting actors. “I knew it was going to be tough, but a casting director never thinks that they can’t do it,” he said. “They’re going to make this movie, so you’re going to find it. Because you have to find it.”
Across the country, Ippolito was reading the trade coverage and decided nobody was going to invite him. “I knew there was something really special that I would have loved to be a part of it,” he told Gold Derby. “But frankly, no one was asking me to audition for it.”
So he built his own audition, shooting “Rocky” scenes in his grandmother’s basement because, as he told the Los Angeles Times, “that part of her house was very stuck in the ’70s,” with a cousin holding a lamp in the corner.

Montgomery’s reaction was immediate. “I felt I was watching Sylvester Stallone as a young man,” he told Gold Derby. “It was that good from the get.”
Farrelly, speaking to the Los Angeles Times, put it more bluntly: “People keep asking me, ‘How’d you get him there?’ I say, ‘I didn’t — he got himself there.’ We hadn’t started searching yet. And we’re like, ‘The search is over.’ He’s the only guy we looked at.”
The Associated Press reports the same sequence from the actor’s side: the tape went out unsolicited, and Farrelly told the outlet, “He sent his tape, you know, cold, and we’re like, that’s the guy.” The director added that a planned worldwide search never happened.
Why looks were never the point
Farrelly told the Associated Press that Ippolito passed that test because “he didn’t do a caricature of Stallone or Rocky and he knew the difference.”
The actor had form in this niche. He played a young Al Pacino in Paramount+’s “The Offer,” the 2022 miniseries about the making of “The Godfather,” after an early turn as young Adam Sandler in 2015’s “Pixels.”
Farrelly, per the Associated Press, was a fan of “The Offer” without realizing Ippolito played Pacino — a discovery that changed his sense of the actor’s range. Both roles share the same technical problem: playing a legend before the legend exists, stripping away the celebrity to find the person underneath.
The physical transformation ran alongside. The Los Angeles Times reports Ippolito trained with weights, ate protein-heavy meals and boxed for roughly 18 months before production, learning the speed bag among other skills.
Deadline’s Contenders Film Los Angeles panel added a call from the source himself: “I got to speak to Stallone about a month before we started, which was really cool,” Ippolito said, describing it as hearing “this crystallized version of him describing his circumstances at the time.”
“Every movie’s tough. I’ve never had an easy one, that’s for sure. And this one fell apart a bunch getting this made. And this took us a year and a half and it fell apart three times in the middle of it.” — Peter Farrelly, director, to Deadline
The production’s own history rhymes with its subject. Farrelly told Deadline the film shot in 34 days on a shrinking budget — “they shot Rocky in 28, but they had the advantage of shooting during the 1970s” — and that he nearly walked before Gamble’s script and Ippolito’s year of fight training pulled him back.
Gamble told the same panel he channeled Stallone’s famous three-day writing sprint, producing a first draft in about two weeks of mornings-only work that, he said, “changed how I wrote.”
AnnaSophia Robb, who plays Stallone’s first wife Sasha, told the Associated Press the preparation paid off on set. “He was so subtle about the whole thing. I met him, and he’s not method or anything, but he had dedicated, you know, like a year and a half of just getting into this role,” she said. “So when we stepped on set, it just felt natural.”
The rollout since the film’s September debut at the Toronto International Film Festival has been the kind most actors wait a career for.
For readers following the awards race, the next checkpoint is the Golden Globe nominations, where the film is predicted to get a nomination. The film is in limited release as of Friday, with the full campaign season still ahead of it.
Ippolito, born in 1999 on Long Island, is an American actor of Italian descent who arrived at “I Play Rocky” by way of an unconventional path. Before his film work, he starred as George Wright in the Netflix drama series “Grand Army” in 2020, and appeared in the 2022 Netflix romantic drama “Purple Hearts” alongside his Pacino turn in “The Offer.”
He attended West Islip High School and later Baruch College, where he played on the baseball team — a collegiate athlete who has since become Hollywood’s go-to portrayer of screen legends before they were legends.
Disclaimer: The views and cultural analyses presented in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Information regarding legal disputes or financial data is based on available public records.