Hailey Bieber Says “Delusion” Drove $1 Billion Rhode Sale
During the event, journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin questioned the 29-year-old entrepreneur on the valuation and sale of Rhode, which was acquired by e.l.f.
Beauty in 2025 for $1 billion, or approximately £764 million, according to Fashion Times. When Sorkin asked whether she had envisioned the brand reaching a billion-dollar valuation from its inception, Bieber described the figure as a personal threshold she would not drop below. “A billion dollars was the number that I said I would not sell it for less than that,” she said, as reported by Indiatimes. “That felt crazy, like shooting for the stars,” she added.
When pressed for the rationale behind that specific valuation, Bieber attributed the target to “delusion,” suggesting that business owners require a sense of “optimistical delusion” to pursue ambitious goals. This response, coupled with her statement that “Rhode is me, and I am Rhode,” left many viewers unsatisfied.
As reported by 20 Minuten, critics argued that the founder failed to provide concrete details regarding market strategy or economic performance, opting instead to focus on personal branding and confidence. Beauty.
Public Reaction and the “Podcast” Critique
The aftermath of the interview saw a divide in social media sentiment. Many users mocked the exchange, with one viral comment noting, “She thought this was a podcast,” according to L’essentiel. The criticism centered on the perception that Bieber was unprepared for rigorous, professional questioning, contrasting her answers with the expectations placed on traditional business leaders.
Content creators criticized Bieber for providing few concrete answers to Sorkin’s economic questions, noting she focused on her emotions, confidence, and personal attachment to the brand rather than figures, strategy, or value.
“Rhode is me – and I am Rhode,” she replied when asked what made the brand valuable and how it succeeded where other celebrity brands had not, a response critics said failed to address the economic reasons for that success beyond the founder’s personal image. Real journalism is back.”
Conversely, some supporters accused Sorkin of adopting a condescending tone or posing misogynistic questions. These defenders argued that the pressure applied during the summit was unnecessarily harsh. However, many in the audience disagreed, praising Sorkin for going beyond the usual rehearsed promotional talking points. “So many people are used to softball interviews and glorified promo where they want the celebrity to be their friend that they are stunned when a journalist probes even the tiniest bit,” noted one user on X, as cited by Indiatimes.
“It’s the difference between social media and the real world,” commented one user. “Those who found the questions too hard should maybe watch the news again and less TikTok,” another user ironized. Uncomfortable questions are not automatically an attack, critics argued; an interview should not protect a star and can also show when someone does not have a convincing answer.
The controversy highlights the tension between celebrity-led brand equity and the metrics expected by institutional investors. While Bieber used her personal platform to build Rhode after its 2022 launch, turning it into a billion-dollar acquisition demands financial transparency that often conflicts with the curated image of a lifestyle influencer.
On social media, some questioned whether Bieber’s success rests primarily on her entrepreneurial skills or on her notoriety, her contacts, and the support of a solid team of marketing and public relations professionals.
For example, during the summit Bieber was asked to choose between Rare Beauty from Selena Gomez, Fenty from Rihanna, Kylie Cosmetics from Kylie Jenner, and Skims from Kim Kardashian, according to 20 minutes. Selena Gomez is the former partner of Justin Bieber.
Hailey Bieber, born in Tucson, Arizona, in 1996, built a modeling career spanning campaigns for Guess, Ralph Lauren, and Tommy Hilfiger before launching Rhode in June 2022. She was named to the Forbes 30 Under 30 list in the Art & Style category in 2023. In the fiscal year ended March 31, 2025, Rhode reported $212 million in total sales, leading to its acquisition by e.l.f. Beauty for $1 billion that May.
The question of whether Bieber’s business success relies more on her individual notoriety or the backing of a professional marketing team remains a focal point for her critics. As of November 21, the entrepreneur has not provided further clarification regarding the specific financial modeling that supported the $1 billion valuation.
More on Rhode
So many people are used to softball interviews and glorified promo where they want the celebrity to be their friend that they are stunned when a journalist probes even the tiniest bit https://t.co/PozokPHC2R
Hailey Bieber is supposedly a victim of misogyny all because she couldn’t provide a proper answer to the interviewer pic.twitter.com/5IeUMv3jHZ
We can’t have actual journalism because of celebrity worship. He’s not being condescending in this clip, he’s just asking her good questions. Not trying to be her best friend https://t.co/xPOK1zvfG4
there’s absolutely nothing misogynistic about this question. what value are you bringing to the table? what makes your product worth pitching for $1 bn? yes they ask male founders this as well. hb is just a nepo baby who probably never had to work a day in her life https://t.co/VLe28jKCrf
He’s not facing criticism everyone is praising him for asking real questions and being a real journalist, not her team paying you to switch the narrative to paint her as a victim. https://t.co/jmED3CeKDg
It’s obv she wants to seem like this sophisticated business woman, she’s even wearing CBK’s fit trying to replicate her essence with not even half her intelligence. The fact that the interviewer had to keep rephrasing his questions because she didn’t understand them embarrassing. https://t.co/UmtIHNECQT
Journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin faces criticism for asking Hailey Bieber why she thought she could sell Rhode for a $1 billion. pic.twitter.com/cbQXOW33X8
🚨Latest News: A TikTok post analyzing Hailey Bieber’s NYT interview has gone viral, examining her manufactured public image and how it falls apart when she’s faced with questions beyond her rehearsed PR talking points. GP also shared reactions: "She thought this was a podcast." pic.twitter.com/h0XFbds9Or