Gunson: Tasmanian Integrity Probe Outcome May Stay Secret
Nearly five years after Madeleine Ogilvie faced an integrity probe regarding a rowing club election commitment, lawyer Chris Gunson SC told a Tasmanian parliamentary committee on Monday that the public may likely never know the outcome of the investigation.
Premier Jeremy Rockliff confirmed earlier this year that both Ms Ogilvie and former minister Jane Howlett are under investigation by the state’s integrity watchdog. ABC News reported that the inquiries date back to 2022, leaving it unclear when or if the final reports will see daylight.
Gunson appeared before the parliamentary committee examining the Integrity Commission on Monday. He said that while certain investigations require confidentiality, the principle is currently applied far too broadly.
“One of the biggest difficulties that arises from Integrity Commission investigations, particularly of ministers, is how to deal with the knowledge that there is an investigation at all,” Gunson told the committee.
Gunson used Ogilvie’s matter to illustrate excessive secrecy. The primary allegation involved a purported conflict of interest during the 2021 election campaign.
“[She made] an election commitment to fund a pontoon at a rowing club,” Gunson told the committee.
“What was said to be the conflict of interest was [that] her daughter happened to be a member of the rowing club,” Gunson said.
Court Finds No Benefit in Club Membership
An additional conflict was alleged because Ogilvie’s husband became a gym-only member of the same rowing club two years after the event. Gunson said that the Supreme Court identified major issues with deciding when a conflict actually occurs.
“There was no benefit that either Ms Ogilvie or her daughter would receive over and above what an ordinary member of the public or relevant member of the rowing club would attain,” Gunson told the committee.
Ogilvie previously initiated Supreme Court proceedings involving the Integrity Commission. However, no record appeared on any court list because strict confidentiality requirements and suppression orders were imposed on the mere existence of the case.
“Not because the applicants involved wanted to hide what was going on, but rather because the Integrity Commission had imposed strict confidentiality requirements,” Gunson told the committee.
“Obviously the starting point with any litigation is the principle of open justice and the public should be able to know and observe what occurs in the courts,” Gunson said.
Multiple Members of Parliament Under Investigation
Greens MLC Cassy O’Connor pressed for an update on the investigation during the hearing, noting the length of time that has passed without public visibility.
“It’s now four-and-a-half years since the investigation began. There is no information in the public domain, as I understand it. Journalists can’t even get copies of the suppression order,” O’Connor told ABC News.
Gunson revealed that Operation Olegas involves multiple members of parliament. The watchdog examined Liberal Party election commitments, resulting in complaints against more than one person.
The Supreme Court ruled last week that the Integrity Commission lacks the power to table investigations in parliament, which serves as the primary mechanism for making them public. Gunson warned that this legal barrier may ensure that the final outcome of the investigation remains permanently unknown.