Guarding Stars Writers Explain Title Change From The Bodyguard
Jared Padalecki and Leighton Meester star in Netflix’s holiday rom-com Guarding Stars, which reached #1 on the streaming service’s charts within days of its November 18 release.
The film is an adaptation of Katherine Center’s best-selling novel The Bodyguard. It follows bodyguard Hannah Brooks (Meester), who protects superstar Jack Stapleton (Padalecki) from a stalker during the holiday season.
Screenwriters Erin Cardillo and Richard Keith also serve as executive producers and writers for the Netflix series Virgin River. Adapting the book presented specific structural advantages for the writing duo.
“When we read the book, we really loved that Jack and Hannah were together for almost the whole book,” Cardillo told Swooon.
“Often with rom-coms, there’s this idea of she has her life over here, he has his life over here. They meet, and kind of have instant chemistry, and then the movie’s about getting them together over time,” Cardillo said.
Shifting the Title
Transitioning from page to screen required altering the story’s original name. Romance fans recognize The Bodyguard as the title of the 1992 romance classic starring Whitney Houston and Kevin Costner, prompting the production to avoid direct confusion.

“I think the best we’d come up with was Christmas Stalkings,” Keith explained to Swooon. “People thought it was funny, but maybe a little dark, and they wanted it to feel hopeful. The Bodyguard was so perfect, but Whitney Houston stole it from us. So, we opened it up to the fans, and they did an online fan submission and picked it from a fan suggestion.”
Keith said that the script retains verbal nods to the original concept. There are several bodyguard puns in the film, including references to guarding bodies and guarding emotions.
Honoring Source Material
Cardillo and Keith worked to preserve key props and character motivations from the novel, such as Hannah’s safety pin necklace from her mother. Incorporating the item proved challenging during early set-piece design phases.
Writing partners Gina Matthews and Grant Scharbo helped the team integrate the necklace back into the narrative. “It was a nice way to honor something that was meaningful to us in the story that got lost along the way,” Cardillo told Swooon.
Other elements required pruning for runtime and production constraints. Keith discussed Jack’s grief over losing his younger brother, Drew, which manifests as a fear of driving over bridges in the book.
“He’s terrified of driving over bridges in the book, and when you watch the movie, you’ll actually see one,” Keith told Swooon, describing a scene where Jack avoids crossing a bridge.
“There was a runner in the movie at one point where Jack, when they’re rushing his mom to the hospital, had to overcome his fear and drive across the bridge, which was a beautiful moment in the book. For many production reasons and length of film, that didn’t end up in there in its entirety. So, as a fan of the book, I miss that. But watching the movie, I don’t miss it.”
The project offered Cardillo and Keith a shift back to comedy after spending five years immersed in Virgin River. Keith said that writing for a character named Jack Stapleton occasionally triggered muscle memory from his other series. “I definitely wrote Jack Sheridan a couple times in my pass of the draft,” Keith told Swooon.
Erin Cardillo, born in White Plains, New York, graduated magna cum laude from Northwestern University in 1999 with a Bachelor of Science in performance studies. She began her acting career at Greenwich High School and later originated the leading role of Melody Dent in Under My Skin at the Pasadena Playhouse in 2012.
Cardillo pivoted to writing in 2015, co-creating Significant Mother and creating and producing Life Sentence for the CW under her banner, In Good Company, with writing partner Richard Keith. Her first feature film, Isn’t It Romantic, was produced by Newline Cinema and received a theatrical release in 2019.
Disclaimer: The views and cultural analyses presented in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Information regarding legal disputes or financial data is based on available public records.