Guardian Readers Describe Terrifying Sleep Paralysis Letters
Readers responding to a Guardian feature on sleep paralysis have described decades of frightening night-time episodes, including paralysis so complete that breathing itself felt impossible, in a letters page published by the paper on 17 November.
The letters respond to Amy Fleming’s 11 November article, “Touch of evil: the terrifying truth about sleep paralysis“. One correspondent, Caroline Staley of London, said she had suffered from sleep paralysis for most of her adult life and that there were times she would be scared to go to sleep. She described an aspect of the condition she found more frightening than the hallucinated figures many people report.
“When sleep paralysis occurs with me, not only can I not move, I can’t open my eyes or breathe either. My mind is awake, in utter dread, but my body is still asleep.”
Staley wrote that she was diagnosed with acute anxiety syndrome in the early 1980s and hospitalised for three weeks, suggesting anxiety might be a cause of her condition. She added that the general practitioners, psychologists and other doctors she encountered showed no curiosity about sleep paralysis at all.
Another letter writer, submitting anonymously, said they experienced sleep paralysis and hypnagogic hallucinations from childhood into adulthood, with the episodes waning only in their 30s, and that they never spoke about them to anyone. They described hallucinations including severe perspective distortion, in which the bed and rooms appeared oversized, full dream states, and auditory hallucinations of screaming and loud thumping, alongside the paralysis itself.
They said they did not know at what point they were asleep or awake, and learned of the condition only as an adult, when they were referred to a psychiatrist over an unrelated matter. Once they understood what was happening, they wrote, the episodes became less terrifying and more fascinating — though they admitted that, in a strange way, they slightly miss the otherworldliness of it.
Barbara Geier of London wrote that she learned the condition had a name only after visiting an exhibition at the Wellcome Institute, where she saw evidence of sleep paralysis recorded through the centuries. She said she found it helpful and interesting that the “monster” is being studied by neuroscientists.
It is comforting to be able to say: “Look, this is not me making something up, this is real.”
A fourth correspondent, Thomas Recher of Ziefen, Switzerland, recalled an Alpine custom for warding off night-time disturbances: Swiss farmers would fasten a Werchhechel — a flax-combing tool studded with long, pointed iron needles — to their chests to repel the Toggeli, a night spirit believed to choke the sleeper’s breath and cause severe nightmares or sleep paralysis.