Grand Theft Auto VI has encountered a sharp divide in reception
Grand Theft Auto VI has encountered a sharp divide in reception, as professional critics praise the title while users on Metacritic have flooded the platform with negative reviews.
While the game secured a Metascore of 99, positioning it as one of the highest-rated titles in history, the public-facing user score on Metacritic has plummeted to 5.5 out of 10 based on more than 45,000 ratings, according to Gameliner. Many of these submissions consist of scores as low as 0, 1, or 2, significantly impacting the game’s standing on the site.
The reaction on Metacritic contrasts sharply with feedback from players on dedicated console storefronts. On the PlayStation Store, the game holds a 4.83 out of 5 rating from 190,000 reviews, while users on Xbox have assigned it a 4.9 out of 5 based on early feedback, according to Gameliner.
This disparity has fueled speculation regarding the nature of the Metacritic scores. Notebookcheck.nl reported that the platform opened user reviews shortly after the November 19 release without requiring proof of purchase. This lack of verification, coupled with the high volume of low scores, has led to widespread accusations of a "review-bombing" campaign.
"That not everyone gives the game a 10 is understandable, but an average of 5.5 is very low," reported NWTV, which said that the publication remains interested in whether Metacritic will intervene to address the trend.

The arguments presented in the low-scoring user reviews vary significantly. According to Gameliner, critics of the game frequently cite concerns over a perceived "woke" narrative, technical performance issues involving low framerates, and dissatisfaction with the game’s story or level of player freedom.
Notebookcheck.nl observed that several of the most critical reviews contain aggressive language or do not address gameplay mechanics, graphics, or narrative elements at all. Some users have specifically targeted the game’s performance on hardware like the PlayStation 5 Pro, where frame rates have been a point of contention for a segment of the player base.
Metacritic launched in January 2001 after two years of development by Marc Doyle, his sister Julie Doyle Roberts, and Jason Dietz, who saw an opening beyond the film-focused Rotten Tomatoes. The site became regarded as the foremost review aggregator for the video game industry and won two Webby Awards for its aggregation model.
The platform was acquired by Fandom, Inc. in 2022 after previous ownership by CNET, CBS Corporation, and Red Ventures.
The platform’s administrators currently retain the ability to remove content identified as spam or containing offensive language, though many of the low scores remain visible on the site. As of now, it remains unclear if the aggregate user score will stabilize or if Metacritic will take further action to adjust the metric.