Google Says It Removed 19,372 Pro-Govt YouTube Channels in Indonesia for Coordinated Influence Ops
Google removed 19,372 pro-government YouTube channels in Indonesia during the third quarter for coordinated influence operations, according to Reuters and the Straits Times.
The Tech TL;DR:
- Google deleted 19,372 Indonesian YouTube channels in the third quarter citing coordinated influence campaigns.
- The total represents about half of all channel removals globally for the same reason during that period.
- The Indonesian Ministry of Communication and Digital demanded a written explanation of the removal criteria.
The third-quarter figure makes Indonesia the country with the largest number of channel removals worldwide for coordinated influence activities, surpassing China and Russia. The volume marked a sharp increase from earlier in the year. Google reported removing 3,598 channels in the first quarter and 437 channels in the second quarter.
The deleted channels primarily shared local-language content supporting President Prabowo Subianto and the government. Google stated in its quarterly report that content removed in August included material criticizing government opponents. The company applies its policies against coordinated influence regardless of a channel’s political orientation.
Google did not disclose specific evidence for the removals, the identity of the operators or financial backers, or any direct links to the Indonesian government. The Ministry of Communication and Digital stated on Thursday that Google’s actions carry the risk of causing misunderstandings. The ministry asked for a written breakdown of how the channels were selected.
The ministry held a meeting with Google Indonesia representatives to request detailed information on the methodology, review process, and location identification methods used for the takedowns. The ministry reported that Google acknowledged its published report lacked sufficient grounding and explanation, which could lead to public misunderstandings.
Channel deletions surged following nationwide anti-government protests across Indonesia in August of last year. Google removed 445 channels sharing government-supporting content in September of that year. Data in Google’s reports show that 99 percent of the 27,516 Indonesian channels removed over the five-year period leading up to last September were closed after that month.
Ismail Fahmi, founder of the Indonesian social media analysis platform Drone Emprit, explained that the mass deletion likely resulted from automated or systematic channel mass production rather than spontaneous supporter activity.
“This is more likely the result of mass-produced channels than spontaneous activity by supporters,” Fahmi said.
Indonesia stands as the third-largest YouTube market globally behind India and the United States, with an estimated 155 million potential advertising viewers. President Prabowo’s approval rating, which once exceeded 80 percent, dropped to the low 50s by July due to economic uncertainty and major wildfire incidents.
Prabowo Subianto, a retired Special Forces (Kopassus) officer who later led the Strategic Reserves Command (Kostrad), was discharged from the military in 1998 and subsequently barred from entering the United States over alleged human rights abuses.
He contested and lost three presidential elections — as vice-presidential candidate in 2009 and as presidential candidate in 2014 and 2019 — before joining his former rival Joko Widodo’s cabinet as defence minister from 2019 to 2024. He became Indonesia’s eighth president in October 2024, the oldest first-term president in the country’s history and the third with a military background.
Always consult with certified IT and cybersecurity professionals before altering enterprise networks or handling sensitive data.