FTC Denies Petition to Repeal Credit Repair Upfront Fee Ban
On October 20, the Federal Trade Commission denied a petition to repeal the Telemarketing Sales Rule’s upfront fee ban on phone-sold credit repair services.
JD Supra reported that the decision leaves intact one of the agency’s strictest payment rules for telemarketers. Companies selling credit repair over the phone cannot collect money until the promised timeframe passes and they deliver a credit report issued more than six months after results are achieved.
The ruling forces providers to wait more than half a year before collecting revenue. A group of 125 individuals filed the repeal petition back in May 2023, leaving applicants waiting over three years for a response.
Arguments Rejected in Federal Ruling
Petitioners argued that the Telemarketing Sales Rule provision is redundant because the Credit Repair Organizations Act already prohibits upfront charging before services are fully performed. They also claimed the six-month credit report requirement places an impossible operational burden on providers.
The FTC rejected every argument presented in the filing. The agency said that the two statutes work side by side and that following the Telemarketing Sales Rule ensures compliance with the Credit Repair Organizations Act.
FTC Requires Compliance Data Before Changing Fee Restrictions
The FTC receives thousands of complaints annually regarding upfront credit repair fees. Agency officials said that obtaining a credit report is neither difficult nor expensive.
The Federal Trade Commission, created in 1914 after the 1911 Standard Oil antitrust decision triggered a push for a federal trade regulator, absorbed the Bureau of Corporations when it opened. The agency launched its modern fraud sweeps model in 1995 with Project Telesweep, a coordinated crackdown on 100 business opportunity scams that set the template for joint federal-state telemarketing enforcement.
The order indicates the commission requires hard data on compliance costs or consumer harm before altering advance fee restrictions. While the ruling specifically addresses credit repair, the reasoning applies directly to similar advance fee bans enforced on debt relief services since 2010.