France Beat Boks After Disallowed Try in Paris
Kurt-Lee Arendse thought he had scored just before half-time in Paris on Friday night, but the television match official ruled him offside.
That disallowed score left South Africa trailing 21-7 at the break in what ultimately became a 21-19 victory for France in the Nations Championship. Former Wallabies coach Ewen McKenzie argued on the Rugby Unity podcast that match officials showed inconsistency throughout the fixture.
McKenzie pointed to an early incident where South Africa threw over the back of a lineout without punishment.
“I wrote in my notes: offside in attack. And sure enough, later on when they scored the try, it got taken back,” McKenzie said on the podcast.
“For me, they had to sort it out at the start of the game, because they’d already thrown over the back once and got away with it. You can’t go into the 10m space until the ball has crossed the 15m line.”
He said that the infringement was obvious during the opening stages.
“I’m not blaming South Africa, but they used it three times and suffered once, and that was the time they scored the try,” McKenzie added.
Second-half tries from Cobus Reinach and Malcolm Marx brought the world champions back into the contest. Manie Libbok missed the conversion to the second try, leaving the visitors two points short of a draw.
The result marked France’s first victory over South Africa since 2022. Former All Blacks boss Steve Hansen praised the victors after the match.
“We keep mentioning South Africa and New Zealand, but France have always been capable of being one of those top one, two, three teams in the world,” Hansen said on the Rugby Unity podcast. “They’re tough, they’re physical up front, and their set-piece is good. They’ve got one of the best halfbacks in the world, if not the best halfback.”
Hansen highlighted the depth and skill of the French squad. He said that their backline remains exceptionally dangerous whenever space opens up.
“Their backs have always been wonderful, super skilled, and when they get an opportunity they score. But they had to dig in to beat South Africa,” Hansen said.
“They got away to a good start again, and South Africa climbed back into it, but for a kick at goal they probably would have drawn the Test match. Which would have been probably a fair result, because both teams put plenty in.”
South Africa turns attention to Ireland in Dublin on Saturday, with the Nations Championship finals scheduled for next weekend.