Following a Year-Long Open Records Battle With Ten District Attorneys
Following a year-long open records battle with ten district attorneys, TMJ4 News published a database on Sunday revealing the names and allegations of 138 Brady-flagged officers across ten southeastern Wisconsin counties.
The Duty to Disclose investigation expands on a previous project examining Milwaukee County. Prosecutors must track officers with credibility concerns to satisfy constitutional requirements for fair trials.
“We’re supposed to be able to believe the police,” civil rights attorney Corey Saffold told TMJ4 News, noting that police testimony often serves as key evidence in criminal convictions.
For nearly 140 current and former officers across the region, credibility remains a central question when justice is administered. The designation shows that prosecutors have documented past concerns about an officer's truthfulness, criminal history, or potential bias.
Legal Obligations Under Brady v. Maryland
The Supreme Court ruling in Brady v. Maryland requires prosecutors to turn over exculpatory evidence to defense attorneys, including any information that casts doubt on an officer’s honesty. Public Defender Kevin Smith explained that the designation becomes a powerful tool for defense attorneys during trials.
“In the hands of a defense attorney who knows what they’re doing, this is very powerful evidence to undermine their case,” Smith told TMJ4 News.
Because no uniform state law exists, tracking methods vary across Wisconsin’s 71 district attorneys. Fond du Lac County District Attorney Eric Toney noted the lack of standardization during the investigation.
“Right now, we have 71 different district attorneys that could be doing this very differently,” Toney told TMJ4 News.
Allegations of Untruthfulness Flag Most Officers
The year-long inquiry found that 81% of Brady-flagged officers in the ten southeastern counties are listed due to allegations of untruthfulness, according to News Minimalist. Only 11 officers face allegations of crimes, and two involve accusations of bias.

Ozaukee County Deputy Andrew Pohl was flagged following accusations that he told a Hispanic prosecutor in 2025 to “give that [expletive] Mexican more time.”
“If I have a client that’s Mexican or Hispanic and he’s on that case, what am I going to do? Attack that officer’s credibility as much as I can,” Solis told TMJ4 News.
Meanwhile, Dodge County Sheriff Dale Schmidt argued that the public release creates complications without establishing proper due process or uniform appeal mechanisms for officers.
“This is one of those things that I think will do more harm than good by putting all these law enforcement names out there,” Schmidt told TMJ4 News.