Federal Judge Orders NYC to Provide Bronx Shelter Resident Data to ICE
Federal judge Lewis A. Kaplan ordered New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration on Nov. 6, 2026, to comply with a federal subpoena for records concerning male residents at an emergency migrant shelter in the Bronx, overriding months of municipal resistance, La Nación reported.
The administrative subpoena requires the municipal government to hand over names, dates of birth, and identifying details of individuals residing in the facility on East 141st Street in Mott Haven. The sprawling facility operates inside a former warehouse on Bruckner Boulevard and can hold more than 2,000 people, though the order does not apply to every occupant.
The decision hands a victory to federal immigration authorities following a lengthy legal standoff. Since August 2025, Immigration and Customs Enforcement has issued four separate subpoenas targeting municipal shelters in the city, all of which the local government fought to block.
City officials argued that the federal agency attempted to bypass local sanctuary laws by deploying administrative subpoenas rather than judicial warrants. Judge Kaplan rejected that argument in a 12-page ruling, finding that the city failed to demonstrate that producing the requested lists would create an excessive burden.

The scope of the federal demand narrowed significantly during months of litigation. ICE agreed to restrict its data request to individuals flagged with specific serious criminal histories.
A special master appointed by the court will review municipal records and filter out names before any data reaches federal immigration authorities. A sworn affidavit from a federal officer established the specific criminal categories targeted by the investigation, which include homicide, rape, robbery, assault, grand larceny, burglary, and assault against a law enforcement officer.
“Dada la conformidad de la agencia con el uso de un perito judicial, y respetando la evaluación de la agencia de que los registros son pertinentes para su investigación legítima, el tribunal concluye que la citación versa sobre un asunto sustancial y relevante para la aplicación de las leyes federales de inmigración,” wrote Judge Kaplan, according to El Diario NY.
The federal court gave both parties a two-week window to submit a joint proposal detailing how the special master will be appointed and compensated. The ruling does not constitute an immediate deportation order for any resident.
The collision between municipal sanctuary protections and federal enforcement highlights mounting friction between local leadership and Washington.
“Su presidente calificó la solicitud como una búsqueda indiscriminada y dijo que ahí se está persiguiendo a personas vulnerables,” Univision reported concerning reactions from immigrant advocacy coalitions.

Municipal spokeswoman Ivonne Rodriguez said that the administration was actively reviewing the decision and weighing next steps. Meanwhile, state attorney general Letitia James began analyzing the feasibility of an appeal against the federal court order.
The sanctuary policies shielding undocumented immigrants in New York stem from local legislation enacted under former mayor Bill de Blasio in 2014.
“Estamos revisando esa decisión y evaluando todas las opciones legales,” Zohran Mamdani told Diario Versión Final.