Experts Analyze Trump, Xi and Putin Body Language at APEC Summit
Donald Trump stood still on Wednesday while Vladimir Putin walked to him across a room in Shenzhen — and, according to one body language reader, that was the moment Putin quietly claimed the advantage.
The handshake between the two men opened their meeting at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen, in China’s southern Guangdong Province, alongside Chinese leader Xi Xinping. It also set off a round of expert parsing of the three leaders’ gestures, the kind of coverage the Daily Express, Newsweek and The Independent all pursued from different angles.
Inbaal Honigman, the body language reader whose reading the Daily Express published, said Trump set the tone before anyone’s hands met. “Trump is the undisputed big boss during their meeting, right up to their handshake, and both his own body language and that of Putin’s indicate that it is the American who is openly calling the shots,” she said.
Trump points and Putin and says, "Who is he?" (Here's full footage of the brief media availability ahead of their meeting) pic.twitter.com/q48ZDfQ4KL
The contrast she described runs the other way at the handshake itself. Putin walked toward the US President “cheerfully, light on his feet,” while Trump did not move at all, she told the Daily Express.
“Putin’s hand is placed above Trump’s, and so Putin takes the upper hand quietly, unassumingly,” Honigman said. She said that Trump broke with formality first, tapping Putin’s arm in a friendly way — a gesture she read as “good job” — before the Russian leader squeezed the American’s arm warmly in return.
A historic first on the world stage. President Donald J. Trump, President Xi, and President Putin hold trilateral talks in China. pic.twitter.com/w2qDiJo8W5
Her verdict on the exchange altogether: “The switch between Trump’s overt, obvious dominance at the start, and Putin’s subtle, secret dominance during the handshake suggests that the two men share a friendly power struggle which benefits them both.”
Putin’s reputation for staging these moments is long. The Daily Express noted he once made former German Chancellor Angela Merkel meet his dog despite knowing her fear of canines, and in 2015 he left Pope Francis waiting for more than an hour.
President Donald J. Trump Addresses Historic Trilateral Meeting with Chinese President Xi and Russian President Putin. "We have a special responsibility to maintain open, respectful, & productive dialogue on issues impacting not just our people, but the entire planet." – @POTUS pic.twitter.com/6dLHVlAl1a
Other outlets found different tells in the same Shenzhen meetings. Newsweek gathered body language experts to dissect the Trump, Xi and Putin encounters.
The Daily Express’s grouping of coverage also points to an incident in which Xi had to physically pull Trump away from a crowd; AOL.co.uk carried a psychologist’s reading of that moment under the phrase “Trump is having some coordination issues.” The Independent, meanwhile, framed its coverage around an expert’s view of the three leaders’ meeting.
The subtext of the gestures is political. Trump, 80, is on his first foreign trip since his party was trounced by the Democrats in the US mid-term elections, and the report he wanted to project strength comes straight from the Daily Express. Putin is 74, Xi 73 — the three global political heavyweights at the summit have serious mileage behind their handshakes.
What is actually at stake is more conventional. Trump said he plans to use the joint meeting with Xi and Putin to discuss limiting nuclear weapons and bringing an end to the war in Ukraine, which began in 2022 with Russia’s full-scale invasion. A US official confirmed the US side also intends a separate Trump-Putin meeting on Thursday, in addition to the three-way session, the Daily Express reported.
In 1979 it was developed into a city, and in the early 1980s it became China’s first special economic zone under Deng Xiaoping’s reform and opening up, chosen for its border with Hong Kong. Since then its population has grown to 18.2 million, making it China’s third-most-populous city, and its economy has surpassed those of neighboring Hong Kong and Guangzhou.
Shenzhen is sometimes called China’s Silicon Valley, home to firms such as Huawei, Tencent, DJI and Oppo, and the Port of Shenzhen is the world’s fourth-busiest container port.
Despite the nature of the meeting, analysts quoted in the report are not expecting substantive breakthroughs when the three men sit down together.
More on Donald Trump
Donald Trump is arriving at an unprecedented summit meeting with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin politically weakened at home, yet perhaps even more eager to flex his power abroad https://t.co/tDckZNxgum
Keep reading
- Gita Navekar’s Experience Shows Ethnicity Can Shape End-of-Life Care
- South Carolina QB LaNorris Sellers Off Injury Report, Presumably Starting vs Georgia
- Trump, Putin and Xi Trilateral Summit Draws Backlash From Republicans and Ukraine Allies (archyde.com)
- Donald Trump Gives Complete and Total Pardon to Pete Rose (time.news)