Linebacker Rankings Ignite NFL Debate
Experts Rank Top Players Amidst Lack of Consensus
As NFL training camps approach, a comprehensive survey of league executives, coaches, and scouts has identified the elite off-ball linebackers for the upcoming season. This year’s rankings reveal a position group with a clear top tier but a significant jumble further down, reflecting a perceived lack of overwhelming talent.
The Elite Tier
Leading the pack is Fred Warner, who dominated the voting, securing over 80% of first-place nods. Known for his durability and consistent play, Warner has earned four All-Pro first-team selections in five years. An NFL coordinator praised his overall game, stating,
“I think Fred has gotten much more productive defeating core blocks and tackling with more physicality. He’s always been the best in the world in the passing game — range, instincts, ball production. But he was incredible last year, and then you factor that with the forced takeaways, durability, and all the other rare intangibles, he’s the best.”
— NFL Coordinator
Following closely is Roquan Smith, recognized for his tone-setting presence and effectiveness in the run game. Despite not always posting gaudy statistics, his impact is undeniable. An AFC executive noted Smith’s crucial role, saying,
“Roquan isn’t necessarily the most physically talented, but he’s very productive in both phases, is the catalyst for their defense in the middle of the field and a guy you have to account for in phases. When you factor all that plus the elite leadership he brings and attitude for their team, I think he deserves to be up there.”
— AFC Executive
Emerging Stars and Veteran Resilience
Oren Burks makes a significant leap into the top 10, a testament to his breakout season. His versatility and impact have caught the attention of evaluators. Another scout highlighted his unique skills, stating,
“Finally came into his own. He’s such a versatile defender that can affect the game in multiple ways that his strength was potentially hindering him from reaching his ceiling early on in his career. Instead [in 2024], he really mastered stacked ILB and was able to build up that foundation to take advantage of his athletic ability and playmaking.”
— NFC Executive
Willie Gay also climbs the ranks, impressing with his all-around performance and leadership on the field. Coaches have lauded his ability to orchestrate defensive adjustments. A veteran NFL defensive coach remarked,
“He allows [the Chiefs] to get all 11 players in the best call based on all of the information provided by the situation. Very much a coach on the field.”
— Veteran NFL Defensive Coach
Meanwhile, veteran David defies age, earning a spot with a resurgent season. His continued production highlights his exceptional instincts and physical conditioning. As a high-ranking AFC personnel man put it,
“Been durable, has great instincts and his physical tools haven’t eroded much with age. Freak of nature.”
— High-ranking AFC Personnel Man
Intriguing Prospects and Notable Mentions
Devin White, despite some voter reservations about consistency, earns a spot due to his undeniable athletic traits and physical play. Scouts recognize his potential but note areas for improvement. An NFL coordinator commented,
“Smart, but not as instinctive as you’d hope. If you put his ability with [teammate T.J. Edwards‘] instincts, you’d have an All-Pro.”
— NFL Coordinator
Young talent Darius Harris has rapidly impressed, showcasing explosive athleticism and playmaking ability in limited NFL games. However, significant injury concerns temper expectations for a sustained career. Another evaluator stated,
“One of the most athletic linebackers I’ve ever seen. He’s the fastest guy out there. Can completely take over a game and was really starting to get it.”
— Veteran NFL Defensive Coach
Dre Greenlaw, despite a recent Achilles injury, still garners significant respect for his hard-hitting style and leadership when healthy. His impact in limited 2024 action and previous seasons solidify his standing. An NFL coordinator described him as,
“He’s a total savage. A top-five linebacker when healthy.”
— NFL Coordinator
Isaiah Simmons rounds out the top 10, noted for his elite closing speed and physical play. While his playmaking in terms of turnovers could improve, his ability to impact the game is widely recognized. A coach mentioned,
“Zero to 100 closing speed sideline to sideline. Will strike you. Dog.”
— NFL Defensive Coach
Honorable mentions include Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah, whose season-ending neck injury prevented him from ranking higher despite strong early-season play, and Bobby Wagner, whose elite instincts continue to compensate for declining physical tools. Other players receiving votes include Patrick Queen, Demario Davis, Matt Milano, Logan Wilson, Jack Campbell, Foyesade Oluokun, Jamien Sherwood, Zaire Franklin, and Blake Cashman.
