Eric Thomas Explains “I” Statements and Advises Visit to Estranged Brothers
In a column for the Chicago Tribune, R. Eric Thomas explains “I” statements as a tool to reduce blame in difficult conversations and advises a reader to visit estranged brothers despite years of unreturned messages.
- Thomas defines “I” statements as sentences starting with “I feel” or “I heard” to avoid escalation.
- He recommends the reader buy a plane ticket to see brothers who have not visited in six years.
- The column ran in the Chicago Tribune and was syndicated to the Press Democrat and The Morning Call.
How “I” statements work
Thomas writes that “I” statements are “a means of expressing what’s going on inside of you” and keep arguments from escalating with phrases like “you never…” or “you always…” which focus on blame.
He says conflicts often boil down to “two people trying to figure out what’s on their side of the street, that is, what’s their responsibility to clean up, and what’s in the middle of the street and therefore a shared responsibility.”
He offers a personal example: “An example I always go back to stems from a habit I find hard to break – saying ‘you made me feel…’” Thomas reminds himself that “a person can say or do certain things that may or may not be kind, thoughtful, loving, or empathetic. And I can have emotional responses to what the other person says or does.”

No one is moving me around like a chess piece.” They also help avoid assuming another person’s intentions. “Saying something like, ‘when you comment on my clothes, I hear criticism’ allows you to follow up by asking a clarifying question like ‘is that what you mean?’ This is going to get a very different result than saying ‘you always criticize me; stop it.’”
A reader signing as Always Learning wrote to the column asking for a fuller explanation of “I” statements, noting that the advice appears often but the concept remains unclear to someone who has never been in therapy. The reader described themselves as a senior seeking practical guidance on the language.
Thomas responded enthusiastically, saying he would love to devote column space to the topic. He acknowledged he is not a therapist and may explain the technique differently, but hoped to reach the same destination of more productive conversations.
Thomas warns against assuming others’ intentions
He offered the example of saying, “when you comment on my clothes, I hear criticism,” which allows a follow‑up question such as “is that what you mean?” rather than accusing the other person of always criticizing.
He added that the practice is about being clearer and more precise with words because emotions and interior lives are vast and words often fail. The goal, he said, is to reduce the fail rate and avoid conversational catastrophe.
Advice for distant brothers
A reader identified as Distant Brothers, one of three brothers born in the 1940s, writes that after moving from Southern California to Hawaii in early 2019, his brothers have made minimal efforts to communicate via text, email or voice and have not visited.
He invited both to visit in 2024 and received no response. Six weeks ago he suggested weekly talks and followed up with two phone calls a week apart; no return calls came. Now one brother is asking him to visit.
Thomas suggests looking at the brothers’ behavior generously: “It’s possible they’re not adept at communication or expressing what they want. It’s possible they’re not good at maintaining relationships when there’s more distance involved. It’s also possible that, despite all of this, they want to see you.”
He acknowledges a face-to-face visit may not be smooth, but notes the reader has “a track record of successful face-to-face interactions prior to your move.”
“So, I’d suggest you offer them a little more grace (acknowledging you’ve put in a lot of effort already) and buy the plane ticket,” Thomas writes. “You clearly have a desire to connect with them and this request from your brother just barely meets that criteria.”
He adds it may be easier for them to see the reader in California and that the reader can and should ask them about the dynamic. “But don’t rob yourself of the chance to see them. There’s more to gain than lose.”