Dutch Court Upholds McDonald’s Firing of Wheelchair Worker Who Stood Up
A Dutch court has upheld the summary dismissal of a McDonald’s employee who was fired on July 2 after investigators watched him stand up from his wheelchair minutes after leaving the company doctor, RTL first reported.
The man had worked at a franchise location since April 2015.
The ruling ends an employment that lasted since April 2015. The judge found the dismissal lawful even though the man is genuinely ill, RTL reported, because he lied to the company doctor about how limited his movement was. He loses any right to severance pay.
The case turned on a single afternoon. On June 29, the man visited the occupational physician in a wheelchair, one arm in a bandage and a sling, saying he was severely limited in moving. A few minutes later, out of the doctor’s sight, he stood up, pushed the wheelchair quickly forward and carried a heavy bag. The bandage was gone.
Investigators had been following him since May, when management at the franchise received indications that he was less restricted than he claimed. The restaurant manager summoned him for a talk and came away with doubts. McDonald’s then hired a corporate investigation firm.
Timing mattered as much as the evidence. Dutch law requires a summary dismissal to be given “without delay,” and the judge accepted that McDonald’s moved properly: talk first, investigate, then dismiss days later.
The man fought the dismissal in court and lost. But he did not lose everything.
McDonald’s had docked the cost of the investigation from his wages. The judge agreed the fast-food chain had incurred expenses, but ruled the company failed to back them up with documentation. The withheld costs must be repaid.
For franchise operators and HR departments, the case maps the path a lawful summary dismissal must follow: talk first, investigate, then dismiss days later.
For workers on long-term sick leave, the message is blunter. The judge did not dispute that the man is ill. The lie, not the illness, cost him the job.
The ruling also leaves one thing unclear: when the man first reported sick. RTL reported that this could not be established from the record.