DHS Watchdog Finds ICE Training Cuts Created Gaps for 10,000 New Officers
Internal watchdogs have identified significant training lapses for thousands of Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers hired during a 2025 surge.
A draft report from the Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Inspector General warns that reduced training standards for 10,000 new immigration officers, implemented under former Secretary Kristi Noem, created what one instructor called a ‘catastrophic failure’ in federal law enforcement preparation.
Curtailed training for thousands of officers
The 19-page draft report, obtained by The New York Times, outlines how the agency accelerated hiring to support mass deportation efforts. Between August 2025 and July 2026, nearly 6,000 officers underwent a condensed training model.
For the more than 3,500 recruits who possessed prior law enforcement experience, the agency allowed virtual completion of basic training. While traditional in-person programs required a month of instruction, more than 80 percent of these recruits finished the online modules within 10 days. More than 10 percent completed the entire course in under 24 hours.
The report notes that training hours for recruits without law enforcement backgrounds were slashed from 543 to approximately 300 hours, while the duration dropped from 72 days to 42. These cuts occurred between November 2025 and February 2026. Instruction on handgun usage, detainee control during flights, and legal procedures for arrests was significantly reduced or removed.
Agency allowed unlimited exam retakes and failed field training
Beyond shortened hours, the agency abandoned its policy of limiting recruits to two attempts at passing the final training exam. Under the surge, recruits were permitted unlimited retakes, with one officer requiring 32 attempts to pass. Instructors cited in the draft characterized the revisions as a major liability, noting that students frequently clicked through modules without absorbing material.
The agency also struggled to implement on-the-job training. Nearly 90 percent of managers surveyed by the inspector general reported that the field-based training program was not successful. In cities like Dallas, the demand for immediate arrests pushed formal coaching to the periphery, while in Baltimore, new recruits were assigned to shadow senior officers rather than receiving dedicated instruction.
Secretary restored standards but gaps remain and accreditation withdrawn
Markwayne Mullin, the current secretary, restored more rigorous training standards in July. However, the inspector general’s office observed that despite these efforts, the department has not fully remediated the training gaps created by the earlier revisions. The agency also withdrew from the Federal Law Enforcement Training Accreditation process, an organization that vets federal standards, because officials believed the changes made them ineligible for continued participation.
The inspector general, Joseph V. Cuffari, criticized the premature disclosure of the draft document. “Such disclosures undermine the integrity of the oversight process, risk presenting incomplete or misleading information, and compromise the fairness and accuracy essential to credible oversight,” his office stated. The department has since reapplied for accreditation, though the process typically requires three years.
The training changes have faced scrutiny following several high-profile incidents. David Brouillette, an officer hired last December under the revised standards, fatally shot Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero during a vehicle stop in Maine this summer. While the inspector general did not explicitly link this incident to the training lapses, the report emphasizes that the agency’s failure to maintain professional standards poses ongoing risks.
The Department of Homeland Security began operations on March 1, 2003, created by the Homeland Security Act of 2002 in response to the September 11 attacks. It consolidated 22 federal agencies into a single Cabinet department, constituting the most substantial reorganization of federal agencies since the National Security Act of 1947.
With more than 240,000 employees, it is the third-largest Cabinet department, after the departments of Defense and Veterans Affairs. Its missions include immigration and customs, border control, and transportation security, placing ICE and its training standards under the department’s broad authority.
The rationale behind the initial decision to cut training remains unclear, as investigators found no written explanation from the department’s previous leadership. Former senior adviser Corey Lewandowski did not respond to requests for comment regarding his alleged support for the policy. The extent to which these under-trained officers can be brought up to current standards remains an open question for the agency.