Democrats Boycott Senate Vote to Advance Republican FCC Nominee Danielle Thumann Severs
Thirteen empty chairs sat to Ted Cruz’s left on Wednesday, one for every Democrat boycotting the Senate commerce committee’s vote on a Federal Communications Commission nominee.
The nomination at issue is Danielle Thumann Severs, senior counsel to FCC Chair Brendan Carr, and Republicans advanced her anyway.
The TL;DR on the FCC nomination fight:
- All 15 Republican committee members voted to advance Severs’ nomination to the Senate floor, where it is expected to pass along party lines; every Democratic member stayed away.
- Democrats fear a third Republican commissioner would let President Donald Trump fire the FCC’s lone Democrat, Anna Gomez, without losing a quorum.
- Sen. Ben Ray Luján accuses Severs of misstating her role in media matters, citing FOIA documents tied to the Skydance-Paramount merger and the Jimmy Kimmel controversy.
The vote Republicans held anyway
Cruz, the committee’s chair, said he learned the night before that Democrats intended to boycott, though Democrats say they raised their concerns about advancing a Republican nominee without a Democratic one repeatedly. To his right sat all 14 Republican members of the panel, including Senate Majority Leader John Thune. When the vote came, all 15 Republicans voted aye, enough to send the nomination to the floor. The clerk read the names of the 13 absent Democrats. There was no response.
“This is an ordinary nomination to fill a vacancy previously held by someone in the same party,” Cruz said.
Democrats dispute the framing. Senate committees often pair nominations to historically independent agencies across party lines, and Severs’ confirmation would put the FCC at four members — three Republicans and one Democrat.
Gomez’s term has technically expired, though she can remain through next year unless replaced. Democrats’ concern, as laid out in the source reporting: with a third Republican seated, Trump could fire Gomez and still have a quorum to vote on key actions. Trump has not offered any Democratic nominees for the commission.
Democrats asked that the vote be withheld until Severs’ nomination could be paired with a Democratic one — one route would be renominating Gomez.
In a committee Democrats’ statement and comments to reporters, they pressed the point at the White House’s door.
“This is not a problem we created, but a problem that the White House can solve,” Democrats said. The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The testimony question: what Severs worked on
Beyond the seat math, Democrats question whether Severs was truthful at her November 10 hearing. Luján, in a letter asking Cruz to delay the vote, said that Severs testified she had “not worked with the Chairman on any media-related issues.” Documents obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request, per Luján’s letter, show she was “looped in” on media matters and “helped draft Skydance’s commitments that facilitated the FCC’s approval of the Skydance-Paramount merger.” The letter adds she “played a role in processing informal complaints related to CBS 60 Minutes alleged news distortion” and “apparently orchestrated the Commission’s response to consumers regarding the Jimmy Kimmel controversy.” The FCC did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the matter.
Outside the hearing room, Luján went further.
“If she was lying about this, what else is she lying about and what else is she hiding?” said Sen. Ben Ray Luján, Democrat of New Mexico.
Luján wants both Severs and Carr before the committee by the end of the year.
Asked about subpoenas or impeachment of Carr when Democrats gain power next year, he said his vote to confirm Carr under President Joe Biden is among his biggest regrets and that “everything should be on the table here to be able to get answers for the American people.”
Where Cruz and Moran landed
Cruz conceded concerns about Carr’s handling of Kimmel’s comments after the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, but said he “emphatically agree[s]” that Severs resolved any lingering worries. He pointed to his JAWBONE Act, which the committee previously passed and which would let individuals sue government officials who illegally try to compel social media or broadcast companies to remove speech — a remedy he framed as covering First Amendment violations by agencies of either party.
Sen. Jerry Moran of Kansas, who raised similar concerns over the Kimmel incident, said Severs’ answers were “comforting,” including in a phone call that morning.
“She was able to satisfy me once again in her answers, including an explanation for her role at the FCC and her lack of engagement on this type of issue as the FCC made decisions,” Moran said.

Why the quorum math matters for tech policy
A three-Republican commission with only one Democrat changes the risk calculus for companies facing informal complaints, the same instrument cited in the Kimmel matter.
curl -X GET "https://apps.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachments\
?docket=MB+Docket+No.+24-186&format=json" \
-H "Accept: application/json"
What happens on the floor
The nomination now heads to the Senate floor, expected to pass along party lines once scheduled. Gomez can remain seated through next year unless replaced, which leaves the firing question open until at least then. Luján’s demand for testimony from Severs and Carr by December 31 is the next dated checkpoint, and Carr’s appearance — voluntary or compelled — is the open question both parties are now positioning around.
All Democratic members of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation, restated their opposition to the inclusion of Republican FCC nominee Danielle Thumann Severs on today's markup. pic.twitter.com/ueWn7ARAb5
More on Danielle Thumann Severs
Democrats didn’t show up for work today. Instead, they chose to boycott the Committee markup. "Miss Thumann's nomination followed a typical process. President Trump nominated her way back in August. She was scheduled to testify before this committee in September, but she went… pic.twitter.com/6C7JCzpzBb”
Senate Democrats are urging Texas Republican Ted Cruz to pull Donald Trump’s Federal Communications Commission nominee from a committee meeting Wednesday. https://t.co/vCBG7Tt8zE
Keep reading
- Memory Spot Prices End 14-Month Climb, Weighing on Samsung and SK Hynix Shares
- Atrium Tests Snowflake MySQL CDC: 30-Second Latency, Preview Status, Cascade Delete Gap
- House Democrats Formally Nominate Hakeem Jeffries for Speaker, First Black Lawmaker for Post (time.news)
- Hindu Janajagruti Samiti Urges Boycott of Ramayana Film (archyde.com)