DB Ventures Sues Coty for $41m Over Beckham Fragrance Sales
David Beckham’s commercial company is suing fragrance giant Coty for at least US$41 million (NZ$74.5 million), alleging Beckham-branded perfumes ended up in a gas station bargain bin and on the shelves of British discount chain Poundland.
DB Ventures has filed a claim in the New York Supreme Court against Coty, the German beauty group that makes and distributes a range of Beckham-branded fragrances and toiletries, including the Classic and Instinct lines and the eaux de toilette Intimately and Exquisite Leather.
“Imagine, then, the shock and dismay experienced when DB Ventures discovered that David Beckham products were being offered for sale in a gas station. How could this possibly have happened? Desperation and greed.”
That language appears in the legal document, which argues Beckham’s “world-renowned global brand is synonymous with excellence and refinement” and that “David Beckham products are a symbol of everyday luxury”.
Lawyers for DB Ventures allege the products “ended up in the bargain bin inside a gas station” and at British budget retailer Poundland, “allowing the product to be sold for dollar store prices and associating the David Beckham brand with cheap, discount products”, 1News reports.
According to court papers The Guardian reviewed, Coty sold at least $24m (£18m) of Beckham products through “unapproved distribution channels”. The lawyers also claimed Coty under-reported net sales by $123m, which would mean DB Ventures lost $6m in unpaid royalties.
Coty has asked a judge to dismiss the lawsuit, which was filed in April. The company argues New York courts have no jurisdiction in the case, and says DB Ventures is using the claim to “manufacture its early exit” from its licensing deal and hand the Beckham contracts to another firm, Interparfums.
Coty denied it had ever sold the fragrances in Poundland, but argued it had the right to decide where to sell its Beckham range.
Coty told The Associated Press on Tuesday: “Coty strongly disputes the claims and has asked the court to dismiss them. As this is an ongoing legal matter, we will not comment further.” DB Ventures’ parent company, Authentic Brands, declined to comment.
Coty, headquartered in the Netherlands, has worked with Beckham’s brand for more than a decade and has produced more than 30 fragrances bearing his name, selling in the UK at about £20 a bottle. The suit now turns on whether those sales strayed into channels the licensing agreement never permitted.